In 2018, officials in the U.S. city of Philadelphia city proposed opening a “safe haven” in an effort to combat the city's heroin epidemic. In 2016 64,070 people died in the U.S. from drug overdoses - a 21% increase from 2015. 3/4 of drug overdose deaths in the U.S. are caused by the opioid class of drugs which includes prescription painkillers, heroin and fentanyl. To combat the epidemic cities including Vancouver, BC and Sydney, AUS opened safe havens where addicts can inject drugs under the supervision of medical professionals. The safe havens reduce the overdose death…
Read moreNarrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Discussions from these authors are shown:
Political party:
Electoral District (2011):
Electoral District (2013):
Polling Division:
@8VS4SD74yrs4Y
Yes and also implement a program to get them off the drugs
@B4LJDLL6 days6D
No, absolutely not. The government should never fund anything that helps people commit an illegal crime.
@B4KXCXX7 days7D
I think they’re important, but I think you should be expected to come less and less. Like a 1yr time frame of windows where you are allowed to be there that reduces over the year.
@B4FMP892wks2W
Yes, drug abuse shouldn't be criminalized, but there should be more funding for rehabilitation centers.
@B46NVM73wks3W
Have a place where people can use drugs but not have supervision of medical professionals , if they die they die.
@B45RNV83wks3W
NO! All these places do is encourage and legalize drug use. Police and all levels of government need to put drug use and dealers/suppliers to the electric chair and all other forms of the death sentence.
@B45NMFJ3wks3W
Yes as a harm reduction approach however there needs to be better treatment and more access to recovery because just safe consumption is killing people and causing more deaths
@B42QT9S4wks4W
they should put that same money for a "safe heven Arent going to be safe in reality and you have them running ranboo instead use the money to FIX the problom by makeing them legal But they have therapy to quit the addictions
@B3QGP691mo1MO
It’s a waste of healthcare services we could be using for people who are actually sick and can’t help it unlike those who decide with their own free will to endanger their lives
@B3K5JNZ1mo1MO
Yes, but individuals with higher amounts found in the city (dealer amounts) should be criminally charged.
@B3G7GL52mos2MO
No, get them to rehab... But we do need to stop them from using public areas as it's a safety concern for other citizens
@B374CZS2mos2MO
Yes but only if your going to help these people with their problems. Not just a free pass to do their drugs indoors
Drug addicts need to be put into rehab. We need more rehab centers to get these people off the streets and back to a semi normal life
@B2XQWN2New Democratic 2mos2MO
There needs to be a set process of habitation and rehabilitation . Where they undergo a certain period of reintegration with the help of specialists. One of the most dehumanizing realities that we may face is homelessness. People want purpose in life, having no home or purpose demoralizes these people . Additionally, discrimination is a large player here as well. We tend to ignore their suffering while shunning their substance abuse, but it’s their way of coping and it should be understood as such. It’s hard to maintain a job without a set place to sleep and shower , it’s hard to maintain it with a drug addiction , and it’s hard to maintain it with the risk of being homeless once again in the near future.
@9WBC5PZ6mos6MO
Yes, but the use of the term "drug safe havens" is a loaded and politically charged term. the correct term is Supervised consumption site and services.
@9W43M3D6mos6MO
i believe that while we should have a place for people with addictions to go we must also not enable there behavior.
@9VJH8YK6mos6MO
I think that "safe havens" are temporary solution to a bigger problem and that if the root cause of abuse isn't fixed the need for "safe havens" will become unsustainable.
@9V7L6BP7mos7MO
Create them, but do so as a subset of rehabilitation facilities. The ultimate goal should be healing; they can use the drugs to prevent withdrawal until they are able to begin their medical process.
@9TXT46C7mos7MO
No we should instead provide more funding to rehabilitation centers to help them instead of encouraging drug use
@9TG78F7Conservative7mos7MO
Yes, this is necessary and they should go further by adding rehab facilities to further reduce illegal drug deaths.
@9TG67VL7mos7MO
I think that drug abuse should be treated as a medical issue, also that the interior of the "safe haven" should discourage drug use
@9TD28DQ7mos7MO
Yes, as long as the "safe havens" are additionally purposed to assist those who are addicted, in the process of quitting illegal drugs.
@9T4L3N97mos7MO
Yes but only to basically capture these people and send them off to a rehab facility where they don’t get to the choice to get clean or not
@9SPC9KC8mos8MO
Yes, I do think so, but I believe the drug use should be limited and slowly limited more to help people with their addiction
@9RTLWCPIndependent9mos9MO
No, we've seen the results of safe havens, and they're not good. Legalize drugs, and incentivize or provide rehabilitation for drug use
@9RMYX2X9mos9MO
No, we should be more focused on treatment and recovery, but at the same time, we should not address drug abuse as a criminal issue.
@8VMZSPXConservative4yrs4Y
Money should be distributed to end drug addiction, not encourage people to do it “safely”.
The decision to open such facilities should be based on a careful consideration of the potential benefits and drawbacks, as well as the specific needs and circumstances of the community.
@B399BKDConservative2mos2MO
Create better supports for those suffering with addictions to get appropriate mental health support.
@B2QRYYC3mos3MO
No this just enables drug abuse and the low chance still of overdose showing these people that it is okay to still abuse their substance isnt ethical or right just because there are medical professionals watching them.
@B2QQFP83mos3MO
Legalize drugs, but create strict parameters to both increase revenue and decrease drug related crime. Increase taxes on purchased drugs and only allow it to be used in the privacy of a home.
@B2BM93X3mos3MO
Double edged sword. Some countries managed to pull it off but this liberal government and a few west coast states in the U.S. have completely failed their program. I believe it does make sense to allow it, but it should always be done as a means to taper off the drug, or just experiment it. Not to take safe drugs for free. It has caused nothing but addicts roaming in the streets setting up camp anywhere.
@B29K7YN 3mos3MO
Maybe we could put more funding as a country into rehabs centers to get the people that are addicted to drugs off the drugs and I know it's a lot more said than done
@B244VCM4mos4MO
The answer is yes. But I think we should also take it further. Not just promote their drug use, maybe also make this a step program to help them take the habit.
Yes, this is a health issue, not a criminal issue. Also, we need follow through; we have to rehabilitate them while in these safe spaces. Support, educate, rehabilitate.
@9ZBK3RP5mos5MO
Drug safe havens should be used as a form of rehabilitation where, depending on the choice of the user, less and less of the drug are administered to the victim so they are eased into breaking the addiction. If they are implemented only as medically-managed drug dens then my answer is a resounding no.
@9YFWP9N5mos5MO
If it is to be a way for them to slowly ween off the drugs then yes, but if its just for them to continue taking drugs then no
@9X4H4HRNew Democratic6mos6MO
I feel like drug addiction should be treated as a health issue, but I don't think this is a good solution.
@nt24216mos6MO
Neutral on safe injection sites. But I believe there should be much more funding for addiction treatment programs, medical detox beds, housing and job support after sustained sobriety, reduced cost counselling, etc.
@9WQ5HHK6mos6MO
Yes, drug abuse should be treated as a health issue, but also increase funding for rehabilitation centers
yes, but under the conditions that they actively work towards getting them off the drug and the end goal being to fully get them off the drug also once entered you'd have a legal obligation to come back for treatment
@9WGXHQL6mos6MO
No. because it's none of the government's business if they have drugs or not because sometimes if they need it sometimes they are in a rush and they grab the wrong thing which is right next to their medicine for them.
@9WDCZXT6mos6MO
No, just ban drugs, alchohol and other substances completely so no one becomes a victim of an abuse.
@9LDLLSN1yr1Y
I agree with the statement, "Yes, drug abuse should be treated as a health issue, not a criminal issue," but I also think they should be trying to help the addicted people get sober in the process.
@9JWWFBK1yr1Y
Yes, but management of this process needs some serous organization, otherwise it has no positive effect. Conditions should be implemented, designed to counsel, educate, and assist addicts to rehabilitate, not simply provide a fix.
@9JWTCPT1yr1Y
They should be hidden or out of the way at least out of the city. Decriminalization of non violent offenders only.
@9G3W8PH2yrs2Y
Mix between No becasue it lowers funding for rehab, however we need safe spaces to prevent loss of life.
@9FYP94M2yrs2Y
These centres are necessary but there should be more to these centres then simply to support the individuals habit. There should be a requirement to go to rehab and get the help these individuals need to fight their addictions.
It could work but I think there are better solutions
@9FKJDJTNew Democratic2yrs2Y
Yes, but encourage using less and less every time, until they are sober.
@B2WZLMJ2mos2MO
Instead of safe consumption sites arrest them all for drugs use like they literally doing meth on the side walk how can you not arrest them? And then instead of jail make it a rehab centre
@B2V94GV2mos2MO
I believe yes there should be a drug safe heaven, but these medical professionals should also be encouraging and helpful to provide resources for sobriety
@B27CPF2New Democratic4mos4MO
Yes but it should be mandatory the person stays there until they come down for the high. I don’t want high people wondering the streets. It should be more about low doses to avoid withdrawals while working to get clean.
@B23KDY84mos4MO
It should be used as a form of rehabilitation where they can slowly and safely wean off of drugs to beat their addiction.
@9ZQRBHRConservative5mos5MO
Decent short term solution to prevent overdose deaths, but we should be more focused on long term rehabilitation.
@9ZHL5985mos5MO
Yes, this could be a helpful harm reduction approach for those with severe substance use disorders, but this needs be heavily managed/policed/supervised.
@95LMVRN3yrs3Y
i think this is a decent idea but also put limits on how much are used and what is used and where it came from
@95J9PCR3yrs3Y
Yes, but therapy and education should play significant parts in such programs as well.
@939RP2D3yrs3Y
No we should decriminalize drugs and provide more government funded rehabilitation programs.
@9388XWJ3yrs3Y
@937NYP83yrs3Y
Users of the facility should be mandated to visit councillors
@92LN4C83yrs3Y
Yes, as a program to wean them off with the focus on getting them in the workforce, prevent relapse
@927ZSKV3yrs3Y
Yes but also expand rehabilitation programs
@927WXT6New Democratic3yrs3Y
not enough info on this topic.
Who the hell wrote this? and it would encourage drug use so no.
@92234D33yrs3Y
Depends on if they want to improve their life
@8ZW44WG3yrs3Y
Yes, but provide rehabilitation and counselling opportunities.
@8ZVW6Q33yrs3Y
I doesnt really matter to me
@8ZVCGY73yrs3Y
Yes, however the nurses start weening the drug users off the drugs, not immediately cutting them off and not giving them as much as they want.
yes but limit them and supervise them
It depends on amount of drugs/ what type of drugs
@8ZSNMKBConservative3yrs3Y
Yes if the goal is to wean them off drugs
@eletichever13yrs3Y
I believe that instead of supporting drug addicts, it is necessary to organize rehabilitation centers for drug addicts in order to get rid of drug addiction. It is also necessary to study the question of why there are so many drug addicts. To involve psychologists so that they can help people who need psychological help for free, so that people do not seek solace in drugs.
@8ZKZ2223yrs3Y
Instead of encouraging support for drug addicts, must create as many rehabilitation centers for the treatment of drug addiction and study the problem of why there are so many drug addicts in Canada. Canada should organize as many psychological centers to support people so that they do not reach such an extreme state.
@8ZHFMV33yrs3Y
Yes, Both to help stop death rates and do health care
@8ZHCJ3H3yrs3Y
If they use it to help with pain for medical problems responsibly.
@8ZGRXJ73yrs3Y
Maybe?? Who knows how’ll that go
@8ZDNQ5R3yrs3Y
Yes, only if it aides in rehabilitation and recovery
@8ZCHQW33yrs3Y
No, It is still affecting the person and still can kill
@8ZBYPMQ3yrs3Y
No, should put the money towards rehabilitation centres and other addiction help areas.
@8ZBC8923yrs3Y
Don' t know at the moment
@8Z6SRCH3yrs3Y
Only as a temporary measure until a permanent and equitable solution is found
@8Z5Z77H3yrs3Y
Yes. Also open more public rehab facilities.
@8YZMY5Z3yrs3Y
No, drug addicts should not be criminals and should receive help from medical professionals but should not be permitted to use drugs
@8YYK6BW3yrs3Y
Yes, but much more in terms of prevention and therapy are needed. This at least saves lives and gets them in a door where they might build trust and be receptive to further help. This is a devastating result of societal ills and the best prevention would be to fix the ills that led to it.
@8YXXC923yrs3Y
I don't think using illegal drug should be supported but if it reduces overdose death rates then there must be some good in it.
@8YV3FHD3yrs3Y
They shouldn't do these drugs in general
@8YQGHTTNew Democratic3yrs3Y
Depend on where they are
@8YP2Q3Y3yrs3Y
Need to do further research
@8YLV7JN3yrs3Y
No, decriminalize drugs instead. That way they can all get the help they need without being restricted to a "safe haven" and without having to legalize hard drugs.
@8YHY2343yrs3Y
If we do this, then we feed their addictions, unless there are options where those who use can have help to stop using.
@8YB8YVK3yrs3Y
Yes, but also medical professionals should use this opportunity to help people with addiction reduce their use
@8Y8KBR83yrs3Y
As long as this is done alongside trying to help them overcome their addictions
@8Y8DK3K3yrs3Y
Yes, but only for drugs where withdrawal symptoms can cause death. Also addicts who show up must be sent for rehabilitation afterwards.
@8XZYC7Y3yrs3Y
Yes and end the war on drugs
@8XZRK3M3yrs3Y
if you do drugs you are pathetic and deserve whatever you do to yourself.
@8XWZTYH3yrs3Y
They should keep trying to put a ban of drugs
@8XWHGV23yrs3Y
Yes, this would lower overdose death rates, but legalise non deadly drugs as when marijuana was legalised overdose rates went down significantly due to it not being “cool” anymore
@8XVNB98New Democratic3yrs3Y
legalize drugs and create programs for people to feel connacted.
@8XJNXY43yrs3Y
to ease them off of it yes, it would decrease ODs
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.