In 2018, officials in the U.S. city of Philadelphia city proposed opening a “safe haven” in an effort to combat the city's heroin epidemic. In 2016 64,070 people died in the U.S. from drug overdoses - a 21% increase from 2015. 3/4 of drug overdose deaths in the U.S. are caused by the opioid class of drugs which includes prescription painkillers, heroin and fentanyl. To combat the epidemic cities including Vancouver, BC and Sydney, AUS opened safe havens where addicts can inject drugs under the supervision of medical professionals. The safe havens reduce the overdose death…
Read moreNarrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Political party:
Electoral District (2011):
Electoral District (2013):
@9ZTRL633mos3MO
No, those with severe drug addictions that are majorly negatively impacting their lives should be put into mandatory rehab
@B3BYHVR2wks2W
#1 Engaged Healthcare #2 Engaged Safe Haven
I'm 4 years clean now because of these harm reduction clinics. I'm clean because i'm alive and im alive because of them and was able to get the help I.Needed.
What you're proposing is essentially incarceration and if I was incarcerated at the time when I was addicted to drugs that would have messed with my mind so much more and I would have turned to the drugs to feel better the second I was out of the clinic.
All that would do would cause or intensify peoples mental health issues.
As a once terribly intense addict thats 4 years clean because of these places. I strongly disagree.
Please, If you dont agree with this I ask you please rethink your solution of "mandatory rehabilitation" / or in other words incarceration
Safe havens should be in non-residential areas where they can be monitored by protection services and where they can provide addiction and mental health services to those who need it.
@B3BYHVR2wks2W
#1 Engaged Healthcare #2 Engaged Safe Haven
Why non-residental?
Just curious as to why you think it should be excluded from residential areas
@9FQ2ZJY1yr1Y
No Prefer to see funding go towards facilitirs that offer help with dependency, offer mental health assistance and rehabilitation
@9GYSNHD1yr1Y
No, we should not encourage drug use but drug abuse should be seen as a health issue not a criminal one. People should not have to suffer because of past mistakes.
@B3BDTW52wks2W
Yes, only if proper resources are in place to drug abuse should be treated as a health issue, not a criminal issue. Look at Portugal as an example.
@8VS4SD73yrs3Y
Yes and also implement a program to get them off the drugs
@B3K5JNZ6 days6D
Yes, but individuals with higher amounts found in the city (dealer amounts) should be criminally charged.
@B3HTCDYConservative1wk1W
Maybe but not only should they be monitored drug users need to be evaluated by professionals to help them become clean
@B3HJK9R1wk1W
Yes, provided that the federal government incentivizes provincial governments to invest more into mental health/rehabilitation services
@B3GDD561wk1W
Only once family doctor levels are achieved and every Canadian has a family doctor, patients no longer die waiting for care should professionals assigned to safe use sites
@B3G7GL51wk1W
No, get them to rehab... But we do need to stop them from using public areas as it's a safety concern for other citizens
@B3BXTM82wks2W
Yes I believe people will use drugs illegally anyway and going to a rehab facility takes a lot of commitment and will scare away ones that are strongly addicted because they don't believe they will be able to commit to it, so something like this will feel like like less of a commitment and overall reduce drug use.
@B374CZS2wks2W
Yes but only if your going to help these people with their problems. Not just a free pass to do their drugs indoors
@B36WM3M2wks2W
Yes, but there should be measures in place to help recover from addiction and reintegrate into society
@B35Q7K53wks3W
Arrests for drugs should be mandatory rehabilitation with adequate housing and social supports upon release, not jail. We need to reduce the reasons why people become addicted in the first place
@B34YB823wks3W
this topic can have both advantages and disadvantages as it can prevent diseases but it also can cause issues in the surrounding neighborhoods
Drug addicts need to be put into rehab. We need more rehab centers to get these people off the streets and back to a semi normal life
@B2XQWN2New Democratic 4wks4W
There needs to be a set process of habitation and rehabilitation . Where they undergo a certain period of reintegration with the help of specialists. One of the most dehumanizing realities that we may face is homelessness. People want purpose in life, having no home or purpose demoralizes these people . Additionally, discrimination is a large player here as well. We tend to ignore their suffering while shunning their substance abuse, but it’s their way of coping and it should be understood as such. It’s hard to maintain a job without a set place to sleep and shower , it’s hard to maintain it with a drug addiction , and it’s hard to maintain it with the risk of being homeless once again in the near future.
@9WBC5PZ5mos5MO
Yes, but the use of the term "drug safe havens" is a loaded and politically charged term. the correct term is Supervised consumption site and services.
@9W4QXDCNew Democratic5mos5MO
Yes, but there should be a limited amount of time they can access them, to encourage them to go clean
@9W4D4445mos5MO
I believe that drug abuse should be treated as a health issue, not a criminal issue, and to an extent agree as long as the goal is to support recovery and eliminate the patients drug abuse, rather than enable it. I also believe there would need to be additional resources available in the case that the "safe haven" does not rehabilitate certain patients and additionally a screening method as not to allow addicts with a history of violent or serious crimes.
@9W43M3D5mos5MO
i believe that while we should have a place for people with addictions to go we must also not enable there behavior.
@9VW59ZN5mos5MO
No. This theory don’t work. More effective recovery methods need to be developed. Stop giving money to non profits that keep these revolving doors open.
@9VTC46F5mos5MO
People addicted to illegal drugs should have to check in to rehabilitation center to be able to collect benefits from the government.
@9VQSDXQ5mos5MO
I think yes we should however it should be very strict and heavily guarded Incase of a breach or a violent patient.
@9VQLZQ25mos5MO
we need more then these they are in a plan but we all cant afford plus to long to build all the ones we need.
@9VPHXL25mos5MO
No but legalize drugs and then tax them so that when they do overdose or need medical help, the money is coming from the taxes.
@9VMP4KL5mos5MO
yes but more funding into social services such as rehab facilities, support low income population, etc.
@9VML4G35mos5MO
We should put further funding into mental health and give everyone access to therapy on a yearly basis starting at school age to prevent drug addiction instead of bandaiding the problem after it's infested our communities.
@9VMHLLK5mos5MO
Institutionalize hard drug users and provide involuntary rehabilitation centers. Punish those committing crimes under the influence with stricter punishments.
@9VJH8YK5mos5MO
I think that "safe havens" are temporary solution to a bigger problem and that if the root cause of abuse isn't fixed the need for "safe havens" will become unsustainable.
@9VGMDFB5mos5MO
50/50, but in case there are such facilities they would help monitor addicts, which may help staff make informed decisions and promote rehabilitations. at least they will not be getting cheap quality or spiked drug products or even fake products, which may lead to death or worse.
@9V9R5P2Conservative5mos5MO
No, I am against the idea because it will give an opportunity to people who are clean of drugs to try drugs and could potentially become drug addicts.
@9V7L6BP5mos5MO
Create them, but do so as a subset of rehabilitation facilities. The ultimate goal should be healing; they can use the drugs to prevent withdrawal until they are able to begin their medical process.
@seaofdisillusion5mos5MO
Yes, but only in conjunction with rehabilitation centers and the staff should always encourage rehab over using
@9V47KTK6mos6MO
Drug addicts should be taken care of by sending all of them to rehabilitation without option, to then help them rejoin society.
@9V3L2T76mos6MO
Have "safe havens" where people who are addicted can go get medical help to recover from their addiction.
@9TZKMBH6mos6MO
The safe havens should be used to try and ease them off the drugs, and get them to rehab, if possible.
@9TXT46C6mos6MO
No we should instead provide more funding to rehabilitation centers to help them instead of encouraging drug use
@9TVQQC46mos6MO
I used to think these sites were a net positive, but after seeing what it does to the communities around where they are added, I think they’re terrible. There are blocks in my city that are damn near uninhabitable now and it all stems back to adding a safe injection site there.
@9TMR89C 6mos6MO
Safe Havens would not help prevent drugs, and would slightly encourage drugs. It is still not right, even under supervision. Instead, we should provide counselling, support, and provide opportunity to stop using illegal drugs.
@9TMG6K46mos6MO
yes this will reduce drug overdose and death this should be treated as a health issue not criminal issue people need a place to go to get help and support
@9TMDBJ56mos6MO
Yes, it helps with less drug overdose and it should be treated as a health issue but it could also encourage drug use and lower funding for rehab centers
@9TLVCVNRhinoceros6mos6MO
This is just a sugarcoated version of enabling addicts, we need to fund more rehabilitation programs so these people can get themselves off of hard drugs.
@9TLF4ZN6mos6MO
They should be in an institution and lowered the dose gradually and become less dependent on it and more independent as an individual
@9TLD6LQ6mos6MO
Yes, but the healthcare professional should help these people quit drugs completely, and in no circumstances should drug usage be promoted.
@9TG78F7Conservative6mos6MO
Yes, this is necessary and they should go further by adding rehab facilities to further reduce illegal drug deaths.
@9TG67VL6mos6MO
I think that drug abuse should be treated as a medical issue, also that the interior of the "safe haven" should discourage drug use
@9TD28DQ6mos6MO
Yes, as long as the "safe havens" are additionally purposed to assist those who are addicted, in the process of quitting illegal drugs.
@9T8XG9P6mos6MO
No, the only time people addicted to drugs should be able to use is when having extreme withdrawals in medical care and in small doses
@9T4L3N96mos6MO
Yes but only to basically capture these people and send them off to a rehab facility where they don’t get to the choice to get clean or not
@9SY6MFB6mos6MO
No, and there needs to be more support in earlier stages, such as kids aging out of foster care and troubled children. If we saw early signs of issues ans addressed them, these people wouldn't feel so hopeless.
@9SQ4V2J6mos6MO
Somewhat agree. We need to get to the root trauma of the drug usage and try to reduce the need for the safe usage site.
@9SPC9KC6mos6MO
Yes, I do think so, but I believe the drug use should be limited and slowly limited more to help people with their addiction
@9SLJBJV7mos7MO
No, this only enables addicts. However, increase detox treatment availability to those reaching out for help…the window of opportunity is very small.
@9RTLWCPIndependent7mos7MO
No, we've seen the results of safe havens, and they're not good. Legalize drugs, and incentivize or provide rehabilitation for drug use
@9RMYX2X7mos7MO
No, we should be more focused on treatment and recovery, but at the same time, we should not address drug abuse as a criminal issue.
@9RC97PLNew Democratic8mos8MO
Yes, not only is this a mental health issue but the facility should be heavily geared towards funneling clients into rehabilitation.
@9R27GGRConservative8mos8MO
Yes, but rehab is mandatory as they are slowly weened off and counselled. Also never near children's places
@8VMZSPXConservative3yrs3Y
Money should be distributed to end drug addiction, not encourage people to do it “safely”.
@8VJ7P3X3yrs3Y
Yes but must go through programs to get them out of addiction
The decision to open such facilities should be based on a careful consideration of the potential benefits and drawbacks, as well as the specific needs and circumstances of the community.
@B399BKDConservative2wks2W
Create better supports for those suffering with addictions to get appropriate mental health support.
@B2SS6831mo1MO
If there is rehab implemented in this safe haven and more responsible drug use then yes. If people are doing lots of drugs in it then. I
Yes, to reduce drug overdose and death. However, they should include counselling or offer programs to these safe havens in which people could get help with their addictions.
@B2RD3861mo1MO
Yes, it would save time and money of medical professionals who have more to worry about than dealing with drug addictions.
@B2R4M5D1mo1MO
It’ll only help with death prevention but even then most safe use sites are under watched and funded and become failures
@B2QWDDV1mo1MO
yes and no, they should provide a rehabilitation center where they get provided their drugs but everyday get less and less so they can get clean.
@B2QW7PJ1mo1MO
NO, that is one of the most stupid things that could possibly happen. The effects never dampen just because somebody is watching you.
@B2QRYYC1mo1MO
No this just enables drug abuse and the low chance still of overdose showing these people that it is okay to still abuse their substance isnt ethical or right just because there are medical professionals watching them.
@B2QQFP81mo1MO
Legalize drugs, but create strict parameters to both increase revenue and decrease drug related crime. Increase taxes on purchased drugs and only allow it to be used in the privacy of a home.
@B2MJ2M31mo1MO
No. Psychedelics should be used in the medical field (so legalized) and used with prescription. The rest should be very illegal and prison time. Enhance rehabs.
@B2K8W4D1mo1MO
No, but incentivize private companies to develop and advance more effective treatment technologies and upstream prevention
@B2C6CJZ2mos2MO
Absolutely not. Government should put that money into rehab centers to give people the help they deserve. You don't treat the problem by providing more of the problem
@B2BM93X2mos2MO
Double edged sword. Some countries managed to pull it off but this liberal government and a few west coast states in the U.S. have completely failed their program. I believe it does make sense to allow it, but it should always be done as a means to taper off the drug, or just experiment it. Not to take safe drugs for free. It has caused nothing but addicts roaming in the streets setting up camp anywhere.
@B2BL3TD2mos2MO
yes, But they should have mental health professionals on standby too for when they need to talk to people because they go to substances to deal with themselves.
@B2BDMZH2mos2MO
yes, but if drug users break the law otherwise then the drug use should not play a part of their sentencing.
@B29QJ6J2mos2MO
yes but treat it case by case thing a lot of addicts also exhibit criminal behavior so sort them out
@B29K7YN 2mos2MO
Maybe we could put more funding as a country into rehabs centers to get the people that are addicted to drugs off the drugs and I know it's a lot more said than done
@B257KZL3mos3MO
How about using no drugs at all and trying to help people stop using them instead of making areas for more people to come in and make it more uncontrollable.
@B244VCM3mos3MO
The answer is yes. But I think we should also take it further. Not just promote their drug use, maybe also make this a step program to help them take the habit.
Yes, this is a health issue, not a criminal issue. Also, we need follow through; we have to rehabilitate them while in these safe spaces. Support, educate, rehabilitate.
@9ZBK3RP4mos4MO
Drug safe havens should be used as a form of rehabilitation where, depending on the choice of the user, less and less of the drug are administered to the victim so they are eased into breaking the addiction. If they are implemented only as medically-managed drug dens then my answer is a resounding no.
@9YFWP9N4mos4MO
If it is to be a way for them to slowly ween off the drugs then yes, but if its just for them to continue taking drugs then no
@9YDXT2H4mos4MO
Yes, but significant funding should be allocated to build a rehab system that ensures people stop using drugs. Not just safe havens. Like Singapore.
@9XSSP9C4mos4MO
Know what because it enables drug use and it can be a Gateway into people doing it as well there's no guarantee that the workers will be safe and fact you're putting medical professionals in danger
@9X4H4HRNew Democratic4mos4MO
I feel like drug addiction should be treated as a health issue, but I don't think this is a good solution.
@9WYDMSD4mos4MO
Yes, people who choose to use drugs so long as their life is still under control can be free to use them, doing this would completely destroy the market for drug cartels. i support this so long as those who are going through a spiral can be protected in the security of their life or whatever they have going for them while they are sent to mandatory rehabilitation until they are clean with significant counseling and help getting those people into a secure and good place in life.
@nt24214mos4MO
Neutral on safe injection sites. But I believe there should be much more funding for addiction treatment programs, medical detox beds, housing and job support after sustained sobriety, reduced cost counselling, etc.
@9WQ5HHK5mos5MO
Yes, drug abuse should be treated as a health issue, but also increase funding for rehabilitation centers
@9WH9V2F5mos5MO
i think if people are willing to harm themselves by using those drugs they should suffer the consequences
yes, but under the conditions that they actively work towards getting them off the drug and the end goal being to fully get them off the drug also once entered you'd have a legal obligation to come back for treatment
@9WGXHQL5mos5MO
No. because it's none of the government's business if they have drugs or not because sometimes if they need it sometimes they are in a rush and they grab the wrong thing which is right next to their medicine for them.
@9WDCZXT5mos5MO
No, just ban drugs, alchohol and other substances completely so no one becomes a victim of an abuse.
@9P8NRFMNew Democratic 9mos9MO
Yes, and make sure that consumption centres are properly managed to ensure that all individuals (whether employees or citizens with addictions) feel that they are safe. Drug addictions should be treated with the same respect as mental health conditions & be provided with similar types of care/education services.
@9LDLLSN11mos11MO
I agree with the statement, "Yes, drug abuse should be treated as a health issue, not a criminal issue," but I also think they should be trying to help the addicted people get sober in the process.
@9JWWFBK1yr1Y
Yes, but management of this process needs some serous organization, otherwise it has no positive effect. Conditions should be implemented, designed to counsel, educate, and assist addicts to rehabilitate, not simply provide a fix.
@9JWTCPT1yr1Y
They should be hidden or out of the way at least out of the city. Decriminalization of non violent offenders only.
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.