In December 2014, the German government announced a new rule which would require German companies to fill 30% of their board seats with women. The 2013 Catalyst Census found that 20.8% of board seats in corporate Canada are held by women. This is less than the UK (22.8%) and Australia (23.6%). In 2014 the Boards of Directors Modernization Act was introduced to the Canadian Senate. It would require the boards of directors of public companies, state-owned enterprises, and certain financial institutions would have to comprise at least 40% women and 40% men. In 2016 the measure had not been acted on. In Norway 35.5% of boards contain women directors which is the highest percentage in the world.
Narrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Discussions from these authors are shown:
Political party:
Province/Territory:
@8M8BFWSConservative4yrs4Y
should be based on qualifications
If a person is a hard worker and can do their job like or even better than everyone else have them on board, gender shouldn't be the reason you hire someone
@8FMTSV55yrs5Y
Men and Women should have the same rights
@8MS74JB4yrs4Y
No, I think the most qualified should hold that position whether male, female, non-binary, etc. But I think the government should do more to encourage diversity in gender and race in the workplace.
@8PNHNSW4yrs4Y
Equality, just in general
@8VMZSPXConservative4yrs4Y
Best person for the job, man or woman. It shouldn’t matter.
@8SWGJ5K4yrs4Y
yes. But they shouldn't hire people because they are women. they should hire women, because they are good at what they.
@8R3WSNH4yrs4Y
Yes but the qualitity and skill of the worker should be just as important
@8SYPXJX4yrs4Y
No, but when discrimination really happen in an organization, government should protect victims.
@8HLYVH74yrs4Y
the person who is most qualified
@8DPLVSK5yrs5Y
Gender doesn't matter, if the team is all men, then that's fine, and if its all women, that's fine aswell
@B45VNJV3wks3W
An effort should be made to seek out possible female candidates in the scope of the board member search.
@B3QNMWT1mo1MO
Forcing the issue doesn't seem right to me but to say there are no women eligible for the positions seems unlikely. Women should just naturally be on boards due to experience.
@B244VCM4mos4MO
It shouldn't be a requirement, however, the person with the most qualifications should be the one to be hired. Gender religion Creed any of that should not be taken into account ever
@9LX8MD912mos12MO
No, it creates a scenario where a business could be punished for unsuccessfully securing board members or challenge existing board members based on minimum requirements. The requirement should be placed on transparency for board member selection so fairness of the process can be scrutinized.
@9K6HR9K1yr1Y
Yes, but i dont like capitalism or corporatism, if i had it my way, rich folks and all higher classes will be slaughtered off while there is no memory tracing of them, their family around them should be involved, at least deportation can be an option.
@9HW52K81yr1Y
Women should not be permitted in the workforce at all, with the exception of combat roles or sex work.
@9G7L7GF1yr1Y
Yes, and no, If they are the best person for that position than yes absolutely, if they are not good at that position, then no
@9G7D2DB1yr1Y
no, board members should be those most qualified and the government should not require diversity within private companies
@9G3VTF42yrs2Y
Personally, it does not matter to me who is in these board of directors, as long as they are doing there jobs with out bias, even thought that is impossible.. So, if having woman in these position makes it more far as a whole for every one than I see only positives.
If they’re qualified, yes. In a political sense, I believe workers should be seen for their skills and abilities, rather then their gender. Their gender doesn’t interfere with how skilled they are as a person.
@9FD8NVY2yrs2Y
Businesses should be allowed to only have women, but not be against them.
@9FX7N8FNew Democratic2yrs2Y
I feel that each business should hire the people best suited for the position. To place a woman on the board of directors simply because of her gender and not her merit is silly.
@8THCSHR4yrs4Y
Yes, as along as women put in equal work.
@8SRVSJT4yrs4Y
They shouldn't be required but should get additional tax breaks for having a diverse board.
@8N73CV94yrs4Y
They shouldn’t be required but they should have an equal chance to be put on
If she's not crazy and way too self obsessed sure, but she really needs to know how to be calm in heated discussion. Please
@MadisonR694yrs4Y
That goes regardless of gender.
@9CLJFYR2yrs2Y
People should be chosen based on their qualifications, not based on their gender. However, businesses could be encouraged to treat men and women equally.
@9BM59652yrs2Y
No, but offer equal opportunities for both men and women.
@96LZ6W7New Democratic2yrs2Y
No, it should be based on qualifications, but more should be done to disolve boundries for minorites and impower them in the workplace
@96D8MBBConservative3yrs3Y
If a woman wants to be on a board of director let her. If a woman does not does not bother me.
@965XVJL3yrs3Y
Yes, but only for businesses where representation would be good, such as health care.
@9566Y5P3yrs3Y
while this shouldnt be mandated their should be an effort to diversify companies as boards and high positions in companies are often made innacessable to minorities and women because higher ups will appoint people more similar to them
@93W8ZTG3yrs3Y
yes diversity is important however qualifications should also be considered
@93MLQGT3yrs3Y
Equal opportunity. Not equal outcome. Equal outcome is the individual's responsibility.
@9389F5V3yrs3Y
Yes, but the women should be qualified for the position and not just given the position based on sex
@9362PYJ3yrs3Y
I want to say yes but I also realize that there may not be enough women in all areas of business with the experience that would put them into these positions. The government should require more diversity in the workplace. If there is truly not enough female potential for those seats, there should be a mentoring system in place to ensure there will be multiple female candidates in the near future.
@925S7CC3yrs3Y
women should not be refused jobs because they are women, but they should not get jobs just because they are women
@8ZX3GXZConservative3yrs3Y
Not a government decision
@8ZVGYLS3yrs3Y
They should allow women, but not required.
@8ZHGL4B3yrs3Y
Shouldn’t be required but if they are that’s good
@8ZC5J9R3yrs3Y
Yes, and women should have access to the same resources that help men become qualified for those positions
@8Z47MQG3yrs3Y
while i’d like to say yes, that’s not exactly being equal either bc if a man of higher qualifications has to be turned down bc the company doesn’t have enough women on their staff that isn’t being very fair but everyone should be equal in jobs
@8YYK6BW3yrs3Y
I can only answer this by saying there needs to be equal and fair hiring practices for all.
@8YYH9TT3yrs3Y
Yes, but it should be up to whoever is running their bussiness that is
@8XZYC7Y3yrs3Y
I would like more women on board of director positions, they are our equals after all and just saying that it goes to the most qualified isn't satisfactory given that women can be just as capable as men on average . However I'm against this because I don't want the state being in control of who is and isn't successful
@8XZC2RV3yrs3Y
I'm all for diversity but this isn't the way we should do it. Having the government control who is on the board of directors could allow abuse in the future especially given how easily this government gives into cancel culture
@8XJHNVS3yrs3Y
Definitely be more diverse with women in the workplace, especially women of colour
@8XCQX2C3yrs3Y
They should only hire the most qualifies person for the job, but they should not discriminate someones qualification based on gender.
@8W9L77J4yrs4Y
It shouldnt be a requirement, I think it should be whomever is right and best fit for the job. Hiring a female shouldn't be a mandatory choice, sometimes a male may have better experience with the job so why would you hire someone not as good? Same goes for the other way around.
@8VZQZDD4yrs4Y
It should not be a must it should be something optional
@8VWKP9N4yrs4Y
i dint really care because if they want to the can
@8VVS8FT4yrs4Y
Best candidates only regardless of race or gender.
@8VRCWKX4yrs4Y
no, but equality of opportunity should be legally ensured.
@8VQ45ZD4yrs4Y
I believe they should require having at least 2 or more females on the board but they have to be more or equal to the qualifications everyone else has.
@8VKN3MJ4yrs4Y
As long as she has the skills for the role, i’m fine with it. But if it’s only a token appointment, then no
@8VK7FWK4yrs4Y
Yes if they’re qualified
@8VJVC824yrs4Y
The best qualified should be on the board. Gender shouldn’t matter
@8VH8P8J4yrs4Y
Their gender should not be what is the deciding factor, it should be those who deserve and are most qualified for the position.
@8VGT9T94yrs4Y
There should be incentives for companies with diverse boards
@8VCK54R4yrs4Y
No but there should be a way to ensure that the most qualified persons are on the board as men are often given a better chance
@8VC3CCY4yrs4Y
Yes, but let’s ensure all board members are there cause they are qualified, not because of there race, gender, etc…
@8VBHT5P4yrs4Y
The only thing that matters is qualification
@8VB4XMG4yrs4Y
Yes, though I don't believe that this should be taken at a federal level since societal standards and other means of dealing with the lack of women in power are available.
@8V772GPNew Democratic4yrs4Y
No for small businesses, yes for large businesses. It's a ridiculous requirement when the board of directors for a small business may only be two people.
@8V6RSWC4yrs4Y
No, this would not lead to femme liberation and it would not stop companies from selecting women that uphold the patriarchy.
@8V5N92GNew Democratic4yrs4Y
Women should have equal opportunity to get there but the most qualified should get it
@8V4ZZL24yrs4Y
Yes and no. Large corporations need both sides for input but it should be the most qualified men woman etc.
@8V2N3DX4yrs4Y
If a business grows large enough, the female to male ratio on the board should be proportionate to the ratio of female to males that work for the company
@8TYY4JF4yrs4Y
People should not be in a high position or on the board because of gender, sexual preference or nationality. They should be there because they're the best for the job!
@8TYSZVL4yrs4Y
It should be qualification-based
@8TX333D4yrs4Y
There should be no business or board of directors, only worker co-operatives with workplace democracy
@8TWYKQ34yrs4Y
No, but diversity on board of directors (gender, ethnicity, etc) is important.
@8TW4MD44yrs4Y
There should be laws requiring ab overall gender balance regardless of majority gender
No, but I encourage Equal job opportunity.
@8TJ5LNT4yrs4Y
It should not be a legal requirement, but one would hope that companies would do so because they want a varied perspective and because they know women have a lot to contribute
@8TJ5QFPNew Democratic4yrs4Y
Business should be encouraged and not required
@8TFVW57New Democratic4yrs4Y
Yes but through an incentive program, especially for all federally and provincially regulated companies, institutions and organizations, including all organizations that receive government funding or grants.
@8T452LX4yrs4Y
if a woman has worked her way to being there, then she deserves to be there, there should be no required to have this or that.
@8SLYPHZ4yrs4Y
Private businesses should regulate themselves when it comes to personnel, but there should be further promotion by the government when it comes to including all sexes in influential positions.
@8SGM6CQ4yrs4Y
shouldnt rbe required but heavily encouraged
@8S3NTLN4yrs4Y
@8RYYZCY4yrs4Y
as long as its even with male and female
@8RQCBY64yrs4Y
Assess prejudices in larger companies, and public ones and work on correcting them. The percentage shouldn't be fully fixed. It's just a guideline.
@8RJYVPF4yrs4Y
Like any other aspect, a person should get a position based on their skills and abilities not gender, race...
@8R3PCHPNew Democratic4yrs4Y
I think that workplaces should be more diverse as long as those individuals have the skills for that job
@8QTW592New Democratic4yrs4Y
I think they are supposed to treat everyone equally. We can't make it a requirement to heir women if they aren't qualified it's be the same the other way around however I would question them if they had none on their board
@8QMNNXJ4yrs4Y
Businesses should be run by the workers, not the board of directors.
@8QHXBGN4yrs4Y
No. However, hiring practices should be re-evaluated as to reduce biases towards hiring against minorities.
@8Q9MT3F4yrs4Y
Board members should be the most qualified, regardless of gender and the government should never require diversity.
@8PYQT8Q4yrs4Y
It should be encouraged with incentives; however, making it mandatory takes too much control.
@8PS9QM54yrs4Y
It depends on the level of opportunity for men versus women, as well as the size of the corporation.
Yes, however, there should not be a quota. The hiring process for board members should not take gender into account.
@tofutofu4yrs4Y
Diversity, and specifically representation, is very important. At the same time, being qualified for a role is also extremely important. Diversity shouldn't be a priority over being qualified. You should not disqualify fully qualifying people from a role simply because they AREN'T women, for example- I think that in itself is discrimination. But, it's important that women and minorities that are qualified get equal opportunities and are being equally represented in the work force and that they feel as though they have a voice and value at their workplace, the the same opportunities for advancement as anyone else.
@8KXVRNM4yrs4Y
people should be hired by their merit. they should also have equal chances at promotions
@8JZZTYR4yrs4Y
Encourage it. There should be at least one on each. Be careful ofcbias to run tgem out
@8J5YKPF4yrs4Y
Yes, assuming there are qualified candidates.
@8H3GHR8New Democratic5yrs5Y
Businesses can have a woman on the board of direction If they want too.
Yes, but all candidates must be highly qualified
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.