In 2016 the International Olympic committee ruled that transgender athletes can compete in the Olympics without undergoing sex reassignment surgery. In 2018 the International Association of Athletics Federations, track’s governing body, ruled that women who have more than 5 nano-mols per liter of testosterone in their blood—like South African sprinter and Olympic gold medalist Caster Semenya—must either compete against men, or take medication to reduce their natural testosterone levels. The IAAF stated that women in the five-plus category have a “difference of sexual…
Read moreNarrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Discussions from these authors are shown:
Electoral District (2011):
Electoral District (2013):
These active users have achieved a basic understanding of terms and definitions related to the topic of Transgender Athletes
@B4KYBL5 6 days6D
If they do not go through puberty, had puberty blockers/enhancers for males, they should be allowed to compete against the gender they are now. If they went through puberty then no.
@9FG9JR52yrs2Y
No unless the athlete has transitioned before puberty.
@9F98QST2yrs2Y
They should have their own division in sports
@9D4YVYKNew Democratic2yrs2Y
We should remove the gendered aspect of competitive sports somewhat to focus more on skill category than gender. This also allows a better inclusion of non-binary and otherwise gender-diverse people in sports.
@8V7G59J4yrs4Y
Trans men are welcome to participate in men's events. Trans women should either participate in men's events or not participate at all.
@8TWMKV44yrs4Y
Yes, but they should create their own gender category.
@8G7TTXFLibertarian5yrs5Y
Transgender should compete against other transgender
@8DRD3FY5yrs5Y
Yes, but with an updated system to gauge athletic ability beyond gender.
@B292M3P3mos3MO
Depending on when the transition occurred. A trans female athlete who started transitioning as an adolescent will have different hormone levels then one who transitioned as a young adult or adult.
@9YHMCTV 5mos5MO
i feel that there should be an option for trans athletes to compete against each other, but still given the option to compete against cis people if their hormone levels are similar
@9W9M54X6mos6MO
Yes, gender shouldn’t matter when it comes to athletic competing and skill evaluations. If an individual qualifies for the given and/or chosen category then they should be allowed to compete in it.
@9W58D5GNew Democratic6mos6MO
I feel like transgender athletes have every right to compete. However, we need to make time to decide on new regulations/rules in order to move forward.
@9W2S8SC6mos6MO
No, create a new category for all athletes to compete regardless of gender, come as you are, know your risks and challenges.
@9VR7Z2Q6mos6MO
This is a very difficult question that will likely not be solved easily, you can’t create a separate category because there isn’t enough transgender athletes for that. And if someone transitions they want to be thought of as what they transitioned to they might feel discriminated against if you say they should still play in the same gender category. I don’t have an answer for this question
@9VPM39V6mos6MO
This isn't something that concerns me, and I don't want to have to worry about it, because I don't plan on doing the Olympics
@9TNBDV87mos7MO
It should be up to the governing bodies of each sport. Certain sports don't need to be segregated by gender as it is.
@9TJBX8M7mos7MO
as an athlete No because if a trans woman is competing against a biological female the trans women will be stronger, bigger and hormone levels are diffrent like testosterone the the female which makes it dangerous for the biological female expetialy in sports like boxxing, wrestling, and Bmx racing. trans athletes should be forced to compete against their biological gender!
@9QPR3YP10mos10MO
no, because it is not fair once you get to a certain age because men are much stronger then woman and they could cause more damage to the woman if in contact.
@9LNCC45 12mos12MO
Yes, but only if their biological sex places them at a physical disadvantage (female to male transgenders for example)
@9KTRK671yr1Y
Yes, but it should be up to each sport's governing body as all sports have different factors to condider
@9JXN7JS1yr1Y
I do not believe they should simply because of their biology and the fact one sex is biologically stronger than the other and would be unfair for either them or others depending what they transitioned from
@9FHJYW32yrs2Y
Yes, but they should have an asterisk next to their name
@8PDQ9CJ4yrs4Y
There should be a transgender olympics/event becuase if you identify as a woman but biologically a man you still have the speed and strength of a man.
@8P8DCNY4yrs4Y
No, they need their own transgender event.
@8NYM4G44yrs4Y
No, the measuring of hormones isn't effective enough to allow them to compete and it stay fair.
@9VWBXVR6mos6MO
Yes, as long as they had been transitioned for most of their life, equivalent hormones to compared sex, and muscle growth is comparable.
@9VW556H6mos6MO
Yes and no, biological males should only compete with males, but biological females can compete in any category unless they are taking unfair hormones that would otherwise be banned in sport.
@9VTJSVH6mos6MO
Athletes should compete based on skill and class sort of like boxing does. Gender shouldn’t matter if they are matched skill wise
@9VRGLZY6mos6MO
the fine line of who should compete where and when should be decided by experts no popular opinion, and gender may or may not be part of that consideration. Maybe gender shouldn't be the way we separate categories anymore
@8V4X5244yrs4Y
Sports committees should introduce athletic events specific for transgenders only if they are to participate in sport
@8RQ6QS54yrs4Y
@8VJY5VN4yrs4Y
Yes, in a separate Trans category.
@8VHSQK84yrs4Y
@8VFPMFX4yrs4Y
When a transgender girl competes against other girls and crushes all records makes me lean on the no side even though I hope for a more excepting world. Hormones won’t change your bones structure. When women are allowed to compete with men and visa versa I’ll be more excepting.
@8VFNKZ24yrs4Y
Yes, but only if they are equivalent in skill to other competitors, no unfair advantage
@8VD4SKW4yrs4Y
Yes but not Contact, Combat or Strength sports.
@8VBY38B4yrs4Y
no. i support transgender equality but formal competition should be substance-free and not influenced by medicines, etc.
@8TYBYFQ4yrs4Y
Yes, but athletic events should be reinvented to be more inclusive while still being fair
@8TXVXML4yrs4Y
The Government shouldn't fund sports events. Private Leagues, Player Associations and Sports organizations should be allowed to set their own rules and contracts in this manner. Individual Sportsmen/women as well.
@8TXC8SH4yrs4Y
Dont 100% have an answer
@8TV492S4yrs4Y
Yes, but different categories need to exist for trans athletes to participate in, including "open" categories where people of different genders can compete against each other should they want to.
@8QVG6XN4yrs4Y
Yes at the recreational level but not at national Olympic level. Professional level that is private none of the government business.
@8QTKBDLLibertarian4yrs4Y
Trans athletes should have their own athletic event.
@8QNBDR34yrs4Y
Transgender athletes should have a seperate league
@8NVTHQ44yrs4Y
The organization should be free to set whatever requirements they want.
Transgender athletes should compete against each other in their own category. It seems that any past or present exposure to androgenous hormones should be relatively compensated for regardless of the current gender of the competitors if this was the case.
No because even if their hormone levels are equivalent they still have the skeletal structure advantage or disadvantage
@8KL8NGV4yrs4Y
Trans men yes trans women no if they went through male puberty. Trans women have an unfair advantage if they went through male puberty.
@8K8V4Q84yrs4Y
I don't support the idea of being able to become transgender
@8K7TGBC4yrs4Y
they can do whatever they want
@9B3CMGV2yrs2Y
Transgender athletes need their own sports divisions, similar to disabled people who enjoy their own Paralympics etc.
@99GTJ642yrs2Y
I have no idea about the science and issues surrounding this topic.
@98SL5S5New Democratic2yrs2Y
Yes, and if we categorize based on hormone levels then we should have all categories based off hormone levels rather than sex
@98699X92yrs2Y
No a new category should be made however if a biological female turned male should compete against males and biological males turn female should compete against male until these categories are created
Yes, if they started hormone replacement earlier in life during puberty
@94BCJHRConservative3yrs3Y
Yes, but go by the standard weight classes to ensure it’s fair
@9443TCH3yrs3Y
This is a loaded and offensive question as it assumes that sex is assigned at birth. No one's sex is ever "assigned", it is determined at conception. It would be more inclusive to rephrase the question so that all can answer it.
@8YN274K3yrs3Y
No, create a new category for trans athletes.
All athletic competition should be based on height, weight, and ability. Sex and gender should not even be considered.
Yes, but Trans people should only be allowed to play against males due to hormonal advantages
@8V5PXN84yrs4Y
Let the athletic event decide on its own.
@8TSVS454yrs4Y
Yes, but only in their own categories. (add a trans male and trans female category)
@8TK59684yrs4Y
there should be separate sports teams purely for transgenders to compete against each other like how how there's men's sports and women's sports just add transgender sports
@8TG9BMK4yrs4Y
Former women can compete with men, not vice versa
@96CJFM3New Democratic3yrs3Y
Categorization should be based on hormone level exclusively and gender should be irrelevant.
@942SC4B3yrs3Y
@8PWLPJS3yrs3Y
No, they should compete in races that are dedicated to transgender people, so it's absolutely fair.
@8YZCDBRNew Democratic3yrs3Y
Have a transgender league
@8X6PZPCNew Democratic3yrs3Y
This question does not yet have an answer in my opinion.
@8VWXDZS4yrs4Y
Yes but there needs to be extra competitive categories developed determined by a board overseeing athletic events and this should be world wide.
Separate category for trans men & trans women, so competing with people who have similar physical capabilities
@8VPDPKK4yrs4Y
There should be categories added for certain events to accept the unique circumstance of transgender athletes
@8VLG64N4yrs4Y
Add a transgender unique to its own
@8VLKD3Z4yrs4Y
We should have a transgender only athletic events,
It is unfair to people who train their whole lifes (females) to get destroyed by someone who is naturally has an advatage (MtoF) even with hormones.
Just like its unfair for a FtoM playing agienst males who will annihilate him.
I love my trans friends, but we cant ignore that fact that like it or not you can have advatages or disadvatages.
I support the trans community but the tech is not fully there for them to fully transition 100%
@8VLHXVD4yrs4Y
Matter the situation. Still very iffy with everything and new research
@8VL5S374yrs4Y
Yes but with regulations
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.