In 2011 the level of public spending on the welfare state by the British Government accounted for £113.1 billion, or 16% of government. By 2020 welfare spending will rise to 1/3rd of all spending making it the largest expense followed by housing benefit, council tax benefit, benefits to the unemployed, and benefits to people with low incomes.
Narrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Political party:
Province/Territory:
@9ZYKJMR3wks3W
Fewer restrictions should be implemented to individuals who show medical records of consistent medical issues across 5 year period.
@9VVH8Q92mos2MO
more, reform the system, those who need assistance do not receive enough to get by, but it is also abused by many. we need to find a way to make sure those who need it, get it, and those who are abusing it, do not continue to do so.
@9SLJBJV4mos4MO
More…but increase for seniors and disabled, as well as supplements a working income (which I believe would encourage feeloaders to get a job…this decreasing the costs of what they would normally get sitting at home).
@9JQ8T5J11mos11MO
Fewer, but ensure the payments are generous enough to help, but low enough to not discourage entry into the workforce.
@9JBTHNJ11mos11MO
Make changes to the system so it is more situational, and will provide adequate help to get them off of welfare in the future.
@9GPTJ2D1yr1Y
More, but through a re-design of how social services and funds are delivered, i.e., provide increased free high quality social services but less money.
@9FRKFKN1yr1Y
Fewer, increase benefits for elderly and disabled folks as well as reform the system so that it supplements, rather than replaces, a working income
@9FQ2ZJY1yr1Y
More. Welfare should be more money/ adjusted for inflation and local col but the threshold for access should be higher, and reserved for citizens.
@9FQ2ZJY1yr1Y
Welfare should be more money/ adjusted for inflation and local col but the threshold for access should be higher, and reserved for citizens.
@9FPVJCG1yr1Y
More, completely reform the system so that it supplements, rather than replaces, a working income, while increasing benefits for the disabled who are physically incapable of working.
@9F7JQGC1yr1Y
The welfare should be flexible depending on the needs of the individual. it shouldn't be a one size fits all
@9F5KMPV1yr1Y
Make it easier to get on welfare Don't make people jump through many hoops to get welfare.
@9DB86MG1yr1Y
I just think we need to be more careful about who gets approved for welfare
@9D4V5MC1yr1Y
Fewer, but work should be incentivised and generational welfare should be reduced by offering education and training to move people into working society.
@9QZCYDN5mos5MO
More, but increase benefits for the elderly and disabled and redeem the system so that it supplements, rather than replaces, a working income
@9MZ47BD 7mos7MO
Reform the system to supplement a working income so people's total income (paid work plus welfare) is above the poverty level in whichever city/town they live
@9JWMJCZ 11mos11MO
There shouldn't be any restrictions on those living on welfare by the lawful creed of the knight code.
Leave it at current rates but provide daycare and job training for recipients. It is a temporary solution not a permanent one.
I think UBI- universal basic income would cover that.
@93QXJCF2yrs2Y
what ever does a better job and is cheaper
@8VTGXS33yrs3Y
There should except in the case of single and low wage families until such a time that universal day are is covered by the government so that parents can work without spending all their money on daycare
@8VSV2HK3yrs3Y
More, but increase for the elderly/disabled. As well as reforming so it supplements rather than replaces working income for able bodied people.
@8VSFJZ23yrs3Y
People should be taught about finances in school.
@8VRPTPT3yrs3Y
More but they should have to do community work.
@8VPV3H93yrs3Y
@8VKZ7N73yrs3Y
Reform the system so that it supplements, rather than replaces, a working income for those who are able to work. Make sure it provides sufficient income to those who cannot work.
@8VJDW6G3yrs3Y
Don’t know. Increase benefits to those in need while requiring them and encouraging them to explore snd use their skill set on a volunteer or paid position.
@8VHVHF53yrs3Y
whole system needs revamp see many people who need help not getting it and people who shouldn't are
@8VHLQFB3yrs3Y
More, but increase supports for education and skill building and transitioning to the workplace.
@8VHB8TR3yrs3Y
I believe there should be a time limit. Some people live off assistance their whole lives.
@8TQFKJ53yrs3Y
Fewer restrictions on the benefits, but only refugee or child immigrants should be able to receive welfare.
@8TN6YP53yrs3Y
Welfare will be irrelevant and eliminated with UBI
@8TN3ZRC3yrs3Y
More, reform the system so that it supplements, rather than replaces, a working income. And make sure to provide jobs for those who are able to work. Welfare should be a supplement and aid to gaining your own income independently not an income in itself if you are able to work.
@8T9SCRW4yrs4Y
Welfare should be coupled with, and conditional upon retraining or educational initiatives.
@8T927WD4yrs4Y
keep it the same as it is.
@8T4S2VT4yrs4Y
A UBI system would be a better and fairer system than welfare and would be more beneficial for the economy
@8SJC9WG4yrs4Y
We should end social welfare programs and let the free market decide
@8SHRW854yrs4Y
Fewer, current benefits do not provide enough support, there needs to be a heavier emphasis on vocational training, and job hunting assistance.
@8SH9LNK4yrs4Y
Welfare ought to be based on people taking steps to improve their lives (rehab, completing training or education).
@8SF7HN34yrs4Y
More, reform the system so that it supplements, rather than replaces, a working income with the exception of the elderly and/or the disabled
@8S6B9RK4yrs4Y
Being it’s should be limited to ones contribution, and paid out at 65 to the benefactor
@8RXLK454yrs4Y
I believe benefits should depend on the individual and their situation
@8RMZQCS4yrs4Y
Regardless, welfare should be phased out and replaced with a universal basic income.
@8RJTV9G4yrs4Y
Keep welfare restrictions same but increase benefits for the elderly and disabled.
@Mc9214yrs4Y
UBI replaces the need for this
@8R7FZBH4yrs4Y
There should not be welfare
@8R52NV84yrs4Y
Welfare programs should’ve be abolished
@8R26JKW4yrs4Y
There should be no restrictions at all.
@8R23V354yrs4Y
welfare benefits directed to getting people off welfare
@8QQRS8K4yrs4Y
Replace with universal basic income. Welfae encourages bad behaviour because its more economical to stay on benthan to work.
@8Q7NQF94yrs4Y
Welfare should be distributed and capped on a case by case basis and as part of receiving financial aid and programs there should be requirements to document spending and consult with resources such as financial planners and "return-to-work specialists"
@8PYVCL54yrs4Y
Reduce inefficiencies and remove perverse incentives before making this decision
@8PP5NSF4yrs4Y
Reduce overall and let voluntarists help those in need of welfare
@8PHQ4764yrs4Y
No further restrictions but give the option to use as a supplement to a working income for those who work but due to low minimum wage, need extra to make ends meet
@8NWJ3SPLibertarian4yrs4Y
System should be changed as part of major tax reform.
@8KG75SD4yrs4Y
Welfare benefits ought to be dependent on completion /continued education, or vocational training programs, as well as counseling.
@8H6HSR74yrs4Y
More with both supplementing work income and increase for elder disabled
@8DZDCXHConservative4yrs4Y
yes but give it a bit more to immigrants.
@8DJL63J4yrs4Y
We should have no welfare and give the people a job, and if they cant work efficiently their income is reduced to only the bare minimum until they can work efficiently.
@8DC73B24yrs4Y
@8CCZXDP4yrs4Y
The Welfare system needs a complete reform. The current benefits do not provide enough support, nor the right kind of support. Yes, people need money to live, and a basic income would help with that, but there needs to be more support systems in place to assist those who most in need. Increase social services overall, pay for it by abolishing tax loopholes. An economy can only thrive if the people who contribute to it are alive, and well, and able to contribute. And those who unfortunately can't work because of their circumstance need more compassion from their peers, and their government officials.
Abolish welfare and adopt a form of Universal Basic Income (UBI)
@8TWDTHBConservative3yrs3Y
More, and crisis programs need to be curtailed more rapidly.
@8TVYS423yrs3Y
Fewer, reform the benefits so they better help the people who need them and don’t conflict with other programs.
@8TTZF9Q3yrs3Y
We should have a UBI and they would receive their income through that
More, deny benefits to immigrants but increase benefits for the disabled, elderly and low income families.
@8WTF2JTConservative3yrs3Y
Regardless, remove welfare benefits.
@8WGJZ333yrs3Y
No changes needed, and deny benefits to immigrants
@8WFRGBH3yrs3Y
Just make sure benifits is for real and qualified recipients
More, and only for citizens only for those who REALLY need it (Poor, elderly, disabled, etc)! it should be a crutch to help you get a boost, not to live on! And require background checks for welfare!
@8W6KC6MNew Democratic3yrs3Y
Replace this with universal basic income for adults and children
@8W4BGQ5New Democratic3yrs3Y
Delete all these programs and bring in a UBI or GBI
@8VJ8ZRD3yrs3Y
Keep it the same but limit time to collect and help find a job for the recipient if they are capable to work
@8VHY7NC3yrs3Y
Fewer, raise the rates to a liveable income.
@8VH22SV3yrs3Y
Basic living should be a priority for every individual. Programs that assist those who are elderly or disabled should be provided with the tools they need to provide for these individuals.
@8VFCSQZ3yrs3Y
a universal basic income is better
@8V99VJ43yrs3Y
Welfare recipients, if able, should perform community services and have training for jobs.
@8V7RPT33yrs3Y
Should be determined on a case by case basis to ensure that people who actually need help get it and to reduce abuse of the system. It is more skewed to preventing fraud rather than helping.
@8V5V9HL3yrs3Y
Fewer, but reform the system so it incentivizes income and responsible financial decisions
@8V5QB953yrs3Y
It should be part of the universal basic income system
@8V2X3T33yrs3Y
If I work my entire life and pay into EI then try to claim it, I can only have it for a certain amount of time - policies should be in place that mandatory drug testing and training/courses etc to maintain welfare payments and only for a short time - it's being abused
@8V28JMZNew Democratic3yrs3Y
I think people on welfare should be expected to look for work attend school, or volunteer. They shouldn't be able to just get $1000 a month for sitting at home and being an unproductive member of society
@8TYN53SLibertarian3yrs3Y
@8TYJGN53yrs3Y
More. Welfare should be tied to vocational training and education, save for medical conditions which might prevent a person from being able to work.
@8TXVXML3yrs3Y
It's a provincial issue. On principle, maybe there should be a limitation on the amount of years, perhaps an end to future generations and immigrants using it. Also separating Disability to the Medical System, not conflating it with welfare.
@8TX2HNT3yrs3Y
Get rid of the welfare system once a Universal Basic Income program has been established
@8TWZ76T3yrs3Y
Should be replaced with universal basic income.
Welfare benefits should be replaced with a guaranteed livable income
@8PKSWWG4yrs4Y
fewer restrictions as current benefits do not provide enough support. As well increase benefits for the elderly and disabled while also stopping the penalizing people stuck in between receiving benefits who don't make enough yet, but make something.
@9CQJF7L1yr1Y
Neither, abolish and replace it with minimum income.
@9CBVDMH2yrs2Y
More, if recipient is able to, ensure they are actively doing what they need to do to get out of needing welfare. Tailor amount of help to the amount of work they are doing, ranging from nearly everything for necessities to very supplementary
@9C7D8F92yrs2Y
Should be there to help those who need it and can’t get by to supplement their wage not those who just sit and abuse it as well their shouldn’t be high income earners in eligible because everyone’s circumstances are different
@9C6GS8T2yrs2Y
Welfare should be abolished and replaced by a UBI instead. So that everyone gets the benefit despite making just above the poverty line.
@9BZ2SK62yrs2Y
No, but more should be done to ensure benefits are not being abused
@9BKK3RM2yrs2Y
it depends, more restrictions on the spending of benefits so they are used for necessities but less restrictions on the requirements to obtain and use the benefits.
@9B55SJD2yrs2Y
it should be easier for those who really need it
@99JZNCB2yrs2Y
it depends on the person
@999V8KK2yrs2Y
More, currently benefits should be only for those in need of additional supplementary income do to additional needs, the rest of the population you move towards a less restrictive Universal Basic Income
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.