Gender identity is defined as a personal conception of oneself as male, female, both, or neither. In 2014, President Obama signed an executive order barring discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation or gender identity among federal contractors. The order covered employers who perform federal work and protected an estimated 20 percent of American workers. Opponents included religious groups, who argued that the order would prevent them from receiving federal money or contracts if they could not meet the new guidelines because of their beliefs. Proponents argue that the order was nece…
Read moreNarrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Political party:
@9FVM4WH2yrs2Y
It is already covered, and should only be applicable to transgendered persons, not people who decide they don't like gender roles and decide to be non-binary (a choice)
@8GPGQX85yrs5Y
No, but we should have laws that prevent any form of discrimination, but since gender identity is subjective it would be impossible to have a law that covers all the possible interpretations of gender.
@B46V7MRLibertarian3wks3W
I would advocate repealing all so-called "anti-discrimination" laws and adopt a robust and radical policy to strengthen people's right to freely associate and discriminate for whatever reasons they choose. We have a deficiency of shame in our society, and our tolerance has run amok, and we can't hope to repair our culture with such laws on the book.
@8Z3PZTNNew Democratic3yrs3Y
It depends upon how it is used. Like if they are brutally murdered for being trans then yes but i feel someone would use this law as "someone misgendered me put them in jail"
@8CRV6LZ5yrs5Y
Its regressive to think that if a boy wears dresses it means he feels like a girl its just a boy who likes dresses
@8MRPD4V4yrs4Y
Anti-discrimination laws should only be used when there is real ham (fires from jobs, not allowed to rent a house, etc.) instead of protecting feelings
@Mitchfynde4yrs4Y
Yes, as long as there are clear limitations on what "gender identity" means
@8GR43MF5yrs5Y
Sexuality identity should be allowed, but gender identity should be allowed if medically Proven.
@abrowning915yrs5Y
this could easily be abused as well
@8T2CVZS4yrs4Y
no, if you are born male you are male, if you are born female you are female there is not more then two genders, animals don't have more then 2 genders because their are not any more then 2
Yes but there should be room for opinion and debate especially when it comes to children
@9D5G4P82yrs2Y
Yes, but don't make the non-adherence a criminal matter
@B3LDKWL1mo1MO
No, gender identity is a complex psychological topic that should be let to oneself to determine at a reasonable conclusion
@B3G3R7S2mos2MO
There are only 2 genders based on biology. Anyone that is discriminated against has a right to be treated humanely and protected as their person, not by their "gender identity".
Yes but only to a certain extent. As long as how the person identifies is whitin the same species and does not use neo pronouns
@9ZNXMHS5mos5MO
Depends. Does your gender identity state your neither, both, or the opposite gender? Cool. Does your gender state that your a cat, or a bush, or an apache attack helicopter? No. Get over yourself, you aren't funny, especially since mentally ill people can take those things seriously.
@9YN74625mos5MO
Yes, as long as the person is at least 16 years of age and has the mental capacity to decide for themselves.
@9WVGRDQ6mos6MO
Yes, but individuals should not go to jail for making mistakes. They should only if it can be proven it was on purpose
@9VTCHMK6mos6MO
Yes/No. This should be case by case.
- For people who are genuinely non-binary, I am very much in favour of having anti-discrimination laws to provide justice for any type of hate crimes towards them.
- For people who take advantage of gender identities/gaslighting/narcissistic entitlement that thrive off of attention, these people should be consequently tried if they are causing unjust challenges for others based on the reasons I mentioned.
@9VGR4J96mos6MO
If and if theres like medically diagnosed prof of the person believing or transition yes. If its some random person made cause I said mam or sir on my first meeting and trying to freak out publicly no.
@9VFDDL46mos6MO
No. If you're making it other peoples problem maybe you aren't suited for the job. It's not like race where it's something obvious.
@9GCJ9X91yr1Y
For the purpose of the government, protectivelaws should be based on sex, not gender. This would still protect the gay community.
@Daboss2o1Conservative 2yrs2Y
It should not be. if you have a PP you are a man, a Hole there and you are a woman, there are no other combinations. and what your birth sex is is what you are.
@B2XG4KGConservative2mos2MO
NO, because if a guy can say he's a women and walk into a women's bathroom and grope women then then i don't think that we should allow it
@B2TT72J2mos2MO
People are so uneducated on the definitions of the word "gender". I think they should be added to anti discrimination laws WHILE providing education of what gender is.
@B2KRS2M3mos3MO
Obviously assault and discrimination is not ok but verbal harassment shouldn’t send someone straight to prison
@B2JKHRW3mos3MO
No because gender identity is fluid (may change overtime) and is not genetically predetermined/visually apparent
@B269GQM4mos4MO
I’m a very, let me know and I’ll go by that. But you don’t state. I’m going to try to identify by appearance.
@9ZQ5RS75mos5MO
I don't believe people should be bullied for representing something different. But medically if in hospital or something related form there should be biological birth option.
@9VLMTC3Conservative6mos6MO
no, there are only two genders anyone who thinks otherwise is mentally ill and should get help you cannot just say you are something you are not like if you are born a man you are a man you can't just change that because that's how you feel yourself you are what you are and deal with it or go get help
@9QPTZ8T9mos9MO
Yes, but only with the valid gender identities like non binary, gender fluid, female and male but people with outlandish pronouns should not be supported.
@9NKSC8T10mos10MO
No, I think it should be talked about and have policies, but not a big enough deal to have a law for it.
@9MFRB3L11mos11MO
Ok, so how the heck am I supposed to know what they classify as? And am not aloud to guess by how they look or dress. I find the idea of thinking your something your not just because you want to is stupid and those people need to go to rehab or a mental hospital.
@9KYBDDC1yr1Y
The often use of gender identity shouldn't be used as often, rather sex should be used. As such, gender identity would not required to be added to anti-discrimination laws.
@9JC6BKV1yr1Y
People with legitimate issues shouldn't be discriminated against, however there is a large subgroup of that culture that's using the litigation as a shield and playing a different power game that I would consider unethical, though I haven't given it enough investigation to determine exactly what's going on there.
Yes, however, there should be a distinction between one being confused about another's gender and, discriminating against someone due to their gender.
@9GYSNHD1yr1Y
No, it is already covered and should be only applicable to transgendered people, not people who decide they don't like gender roles and decide to be non-binary.
@9DHRMNZ2yrs2Y
If you’re a plant people should laugh at you. Other than that, I support gender identity added to anti-discrimination laws.
@9FD85P82yrs2Y
I am neutral to these choices and I would like to stay out of the debate on gender, you can identify yourself as whatever you wish and I will not care.
im fine with male, female, trans and non binary but i feel like the other genders are unnessasary
@9F98QST2yrs2Y
go over basic anti discrimination laws and that no one should be attacked for who they are, however i dont agree with compelled speech
@9F7DNYY2yrs2Y
Yes, but restrict the protected identities to male, female, both, and neither.
@9F5KMPV2yrs2Y
Trans people should be free from discrimination, recieve government support and have access to medical care and resources. A person doesn't choose to be trans so they should be protected from discrimination.
@9F5FC8S 2yrs2Y
I’m undecided on how I feel about this topic in a broad stroke and currently consider it less important amongst other more pressing issues.
@8YYK6BW3yrs3Y
I thought it already was, but if not, such discrimination should not be allowed.
@8TYY4JF4yrs4Y
Since when did society start adding all these labels to people?? This is part of what is causing such mental health issues, people feel they don't fit into any 1 specific group STOP ALREADY!!!
@8TNGFRXConservative4yrs4Y
It shouldn’t be forced upon people
@8RZGYHN4yrs4Y
Yes, but only the person is proven to be transgender as is identifying and transitioning to the opposite gender.
@8VB2DHN4yrs4Y
People should be able to identify as what ever they want. However, scientifically there is only two genders and that is what all legal documents should show, only two.
No, how about we are all “human.” Why does it have to be so technical. I think people want more boxes, more confusion to put us in, a larger divide. We need unify, not separating us further and further from each other. Social media has already done that so successfully. People want to feel special, and that they are different and somehow disadvantaged or unique and have a reason to complain, or point the finger at someone. Less boundaries, less boxes, more leading with love and kindness. Your a person, I’m a person that’s it. We should be equally treated if we are purp… Read more
@8P3F3JT4yrs4Y
No. There are three identities. Male, female, and the unfortunate margin of people born deformed.
We should absolutely help that unfortune margin of peolek to assign the gender of their choosing. However it must fall into one of three categories. Male. Female. Other
@8NVX5TH4yrs4Y
Man I don’t know. This is a complex issue and I wish there was more open debate.
@8VCBZW34yrs4Y
This is already covered under Canada's charter of rights and freedoms
@8TTDS3B4yrs4Y
Yes As long as it doesn’t infringe upon free speech or other rights
@96JGN832yrs2Y
I think we should have a true debate first
@93QXJCF3yrs3Y
yes but limit it to male, female, or n/a anything else is extra and unneeded
@92RTRZZ3yrs3Y
Anti-discrimination laws are too strict, and run counter to our right to free speech. No speech should be limited, unless it is actively calling for violence, or harm.
@8ZR8QDRConservative3yrs3Y
No, all discrimination is wrong, therefore laws should not be made for special interests or minorities.
@8ZQ72FN3yrs3Y
It's important that people give others the chance to try and understand different gender identities and not be criminalized for adaptation time
@8ZM4Q6D3yrs3Y
Yes but as I stated before, everyone's entitled to opinions in a moral and ethical extent, ie discrimination should be looked down upon.
Yes, but descrimination laws should be universal
@8ZKR6Z83yrs3Y
No, It is too much of Anti-discrimination.
@8ZKQNKH3yrs3Y
If the pronouns are not weird
@8ZHLXYW3yrs3Y
I think all people should be treated with respect and not discriminated against but I do think gender identity is linked with mental health
@8ZHHYDM3yrs3Y
Sex is a biological and unchangeable thing. Gender identify his more of a social thing, a social identity. Gender identity needs to be respected but we can't put it in laws, because it is something that can change. In laws identity needs to be solid, in things like legal documents and passports for example.
@8ZHCM233yrs3Y
i can not respond to this question at this time
@8ZGYVY43yrs3Y
сложно ответить на этот вопрос
@8ZGRXJ73yrs3Y
Gender is gender be who u wanna be
@8ZFWNWG3yrs3Y
no, only biological “genders” should be recognized.
@8ZFGRY33yrs3Y
I don’t understand the context/question
@8ZBS5B83yrs3Y
Yes but only if someones isn't claiming there gender identity something completely absurd for example a potato just to draw attention.
@8ZBJDHQ3yrs3Y
they're making gender identity too big of an issue when we should be focussing on over stuff. gender identity is important to an extent but is over ruled in some circumstances.
@8Z8Z3QW3yrs3Y
We should define gender and agree about what were actually talking about before making a decision
@8Z87ZRQ3yrs3Y
Yes and stop sacrificing women's rights to appease your white guilt.
@8Z82ZM23yrs3Y
And I have Zero use for one Jordan Petersons viewpoints and rhetoric. I think his podcast fuels social and political discord.
@8Z6YT4Q3yrs3Y
@8Z5RJYQConservative3yrs3Y
It's not myproblem nor myown fight.
@8Z4W5PT3yrs3Y
Depends on the impact, sports teams no, firing yes
@8Z44KLR3yrs3Y
No, unless gender identity is clearly defined and does not involve compelled speech laws or gender identity diversity requirements. Also the idea of gender identity should never be taught in schools.
@8Z3V84Y3yrs3Y
There are 2 genders if uou disagree there mental hospitals.
Yes, but I don't have to agree with it. I will respect the person.
@8Z3M25Q3yrs3Y
I don't have an opinion about this.
@8Z3FZNL3yrs3Y
people can change genders, but there should be a limit as to what is classified as a gender and what is not
@8Z3B7B53yrs3Y
Yes, but gender identity needs a clear definition, gender identity should never be taught in schools, and no compelled speech legislation should ever be implemented
gender identity should be taken more seriously.
@8YTR7BFConservative3yrs3Y
Your a boy or girl there is no other way around that.
@8YTD7SD3yrs3Y
Gender identity is anoyying people say there dogs and it’s just dumb your either male or female pick one
@8YTCYNC3yrs3Y
Yea yet we should provide funds for more research and care
@8YJ7WXZConservative3yrs3Y
It does not matter what someones gender identity is as long as they receive fair treatment
@8YG2NCHNew Democratic3yrs3Y
I believe there are only two genders, but I respect everyone doing what will make them comfortable
@8YFHZQZConservative3yrs3Y
Yes, but there should be a recognized list of genders and gender identities to allow proper representation and the means to be able to enforce laws involving them
@8YDGTLW3yrs3Y
@8YCSM7H3yrs3Y
Yes, the government should do more to protect minorities from discrimination BUT to a certain extent
@8YCQ7HQ3yrs3Y
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.