Should Canada increase or decrease the amount of temporary work visas given to high-skilled immigrant workers?
Skilled temporary work visas are usually given to foreign scientists, engineers, programmers, architects, executives, and other positions or fields where demand outpaces supply. Most businesses argue that hiring skilled foreign workers allows them to competitively fill positions which are in high demand. Opponents argue that skilled immigrants decrease middle class wages and job tenure.
Narrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Discussions from these authors are shown:
Political party:
Province/Territory:
@57MXLNH4yrs4Y
Educational institutions & government should join to evaluate the need for skilled workers, then provide $$$ incentives such as free tuition & small living allowance to Canadians willing to train to fill these gaps. We have too many unskilled, unemployed arts degrees, and educators are still pushing students to a prestigious ARTS program.
@B3HMKQQ1mo1MO
The system needs to be regulated so that companies can not abuse the use of these visas and those brought in to do the work.
@B3G5TN4New Democratic1mo1MO
Regardless, more steps should be taken against companies exploiting temporary foreign workers. Employers using this type of visa frequently abuse immigrant employees.
@9VS9N3RLibertarian6mos6MO
Companies should be allowed to hire foreign workers, but the government will provide no incentives to do so, and companies must pay all expenses to hire these foreign workers (sponsorship)
@9LJVNVS12mos12MO
They shouldn't bother creating temporary work visas. It's either they are a citizen or not a citizen, because that most workers goals anyways in this program.
@9FB722T2yrs2Y
Decrease until the rate of growth in housing and infrastructure can balance with immigration
@B2TS2VL2mos2MO
Yes, as long as it doesn't cause significant harm to our infrastructure, housing market, healthcare, etc.
@B24T7394mos4MO
Increase, but only in fields that are not over-saturated, and pay all workers fair and reasonable wages.
@9ZYVF3M4mos4MO
Companies are taking advantage of this program to hire immigrants at a lower cost instead of hiring Canadian citizens
@9W27QN26mos6MO
the government needs to provide opportunities for these highly educated immigrant to get jobs in their fields because often they end up working for Uber because they cant get a job in their field. another major issue is that they don't have the canadian certifications for their fields of expertise but are quite educated and have the certificates that their country of origin needs.
@9RDSKS39mos9MO
Increase but immigrants from poor countries need support in order to gain their equivalencies or else people with degrees end up driving taxis.
@9RCBSYB9mos9MO
We should look within for people to fill these positions first. Find people with potential and promote training for citizens to fill these roles rather than staying unemployed. Fair wages for fair work. Companies that are willing to train citizens rather than hire immigrants at a low cost could get higher government ratings and media promotion benefits.
@9G28PF42yrs2Y
Increase, with a proper background check and screening of their record at their current country as well as paying them what a person who would have that job as a citizen of Canada
@9FP3QX22yrs2Y
Increase for now, but visa green cards should not be a requirement for immigration.
@9F9XLSYConservative2yrs2Y
Increase, as long as their education is verified via stringent professional testing
@9MLXWMN11mos11MO
The definition of high-skilled immigrant workers needs a good overhaul. While we need a lot more doctors, all we are getting are food delivery drivers.
@9ML8M3H11mos11MO
increase, because canada benefits from the workers, but it should be regulated so that these workers are treated fairly and compensated accordingly
@9G2PHDK2yrs2Y
Increase but place restrictions on allowing companies to take advantage of this program to decrease wages.
@8PW9SHK4yrs4Y
Decrease the visas via the creation of programs that make it easier for skilled workers to immigrate to Canada on a permanent basis. This would eliminate the incentive for companies to hire temporary foreign workers as a cost saving measure, and create a new pathway to citizenship for skilled workers.
@8KLCJ9TNew Democratic4yrs4Y
Keep the current amount the same, but implement policies that prevent companies from taking advantage to decrease wages/exploit workers.
@95SFXHS3yrs3Y
Priority should be given to young Canadians wanted to step in and have an opportunity VS sourcing it all elsewhere.
@95GQYXPNew Democratic3yrs3Y
increase but regulate wages accordingly
@92RTRZZ3yrs3Y
Stay the same, incentivize citizens to work these jobs.
@8VXL57D4yrs4Y
Increase, and the government and a third-party should review each buisness hiring high-skilled immigrants ensuring they are compensated the same as if they were a citizen.
@8VPMD3QConservative4yrs4Y
Increase, but only if the immigrants are brought in to the country with eventual citizenship in mind.
@8VKBKM84yrs4Y
Increase, but ensure immigrant workers are being treated well by setting up a monitoring agency.
@8VJDPWF4yrs4Y
Increase if we are in short supply of that skill Decrease if we have a surplus
@8VBQPPS4yrs4Y
Increase with more incentives where companies are held accountable if they take advantage
@8VBHPDB4yrs4Y
Increase, and government should impose measures to ensure the workers are treated fairly
@8V9NNNRNew Democratic4yrs4Y
Increase and implement protection measures so workers are not exploited.
@8TXCC9Y4yrs4Y
Target high skilled workers but ensure that companies cant take advantage to decrease wages
@8TX6Z4N4yrs4Y
Increase but with more governance over the ratio of Canadian citizen workers
@8TX5JVB4yrs4Y
Regardless, the government should do more to penalize companies that are taking advantage if this program to decrease wages
@8TWXBFC4yrs4Y
I am satisfied with the current amount, No welfare or work for Welfare would make adults go to school to improve themselves.
Increase, however Canada should also give an opportunity to low-skilled immigrant workers to assist them in finding a job suitable for them to be able to live here.
@8TP8W834yrs4Y
Increase, and prevent companies from giving them lower wages than other people.
@8TJDQSV4yrs4Y
Increase the amount of Visa but increase their wages.
@8T8PGV94yrs4Y
we should proiritise our own citisans
@8SM79NB4yrs4Y
They should be eliminated.
@8S73DY84yrs4Y
I would consult economists on this issue, politicians aren't exactly the most competent
@firozsasi4yrs4Y
Use virtual system to achieve economic effectiveness
@8R23V354yrs4Y
maintain but increase funding to encourage high skills/demand occupations development at home
@8QZTFS34yrs4Y
We should be gearing more people to the trades to be able to fill these jobs
@8QMB9VG4yrs4Y
Remain the same, and the government should provide more incentives to prepare our citizens for these jobs
@8QHTWWR4yrs4Y
increase, but punish companies for taking advantage of the immigrant workers for cheaper labour
Increase, and ensure these workers have adequate protections in place to prevent them from being exploited and mistreated.
@8PP5NSF4yrs4Y
Neither - let individuals decide for themselves
@8PCSLHK4yrs4Y
it should stay the way is currently is
@8P3F3JT4yrs4Y
Eliminate the Work Visa entirely.
Create a minimum wage tax that only applies to companies that pay any of their employees minimum wage, companies that pay higher are exempt as long as none of their employees, or contractors employees make minimum wage or less .
Decrease, importing immigrants to fill roles in canada suppresses wages and increases competition regardless of the job or class of the persons imported
@Staplefsa5yrs5Y
If there is someone with a higher skill then bring them in but they should be paid the same amount
There is no such thing as a low or high skilled worker.
@92JWPGRNew Democratic3yrs3Y
Increase, our society is built on immigrants
@99VVCCYConservative2yrs2Y
Have the required amount don't add more and encourage it but don't discourage it. In essences the Government should stay out and not have any involvement.
@96QP3KD2yrs2Y
@96JJRBT2yrs2Y
There is no such as a high skilled worker. They are all the same.
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.