Should Canada increase or decrease the amount of temporary work visas given to high-skilled immigrant workers?
Skilled temporary work visas are usually given to foreign scientists, engineers, programmers, architects, executives, and other positions or fields where demand outpaces supply. Most businesses argue that hiring skilled foreign workers allows them to competitively fill positions which are in high demand. Opponents argue that skilled immigrants decrease middle class wages and job tenure.
Narrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Discussions from these authors are shown:
Political party:
Province/Territory:
@4VQ296S4yrs4Y
Our education system should be tailored to the job market. Too much utter waste of artsy fartsy programs when people can't find a plumber.
@9VDRGX46mos6MO
if they are high skilled, but they have committed a crime recently you should not give a visa but otherwise you should.
@9V9LMB66mos6MO
Temporarily decrease and the government should provide more incentives to prepare our citizens for these jobs and once the housing crisis is fixed then we can increase the amount of work visas given
@9T32KG97mos7MO
What difference does it make. Anyone who has a degree isn't allowed to practice medicine unless they complete school here in Canada.
@B292M3P3mos3MO
When unemployment is above 2% we don't need TFWPs. We should focus on building skills for today and tomorrow not yesterday.
@9WYDMSD6mos6MO
Eliminate and put laws in place to prevent a program similar to it from ever being implemented again.
Make it easier for current immigrants to transfer their skills without the next to spend high amounts of time and money to retrain for skills they already have.
@9RBPVRK9mos9MO
Temporary work visas should continue to be used to fill shortages in critical industries (ie health care), but should be ceased entirely for non-critical industries (retail, restaurants)
@8XZNFFC3yrs3Y
Regardless, the government should not be involved in this matter.
@8WMPBWQ3yrs3Y
Neither decrease nor increase, but add funding and incentives for our own citizens to be capable of these jobs.
@8VSPH8F4yrs4Y
Promote jobs for citizens, then make the process easier for better paid foreign workers if they are necessary.
@8VJH7P54yrs4Y
With the amount of tax we pay we should be able to train and educate people that are already her and looking to improve their skill sets
@8VH294R4yrs4Y
Don’t know enough to provide an answer, it matters to me how long term the temporary work visa is. Since I don’t know how long a temporary work visa is, I cannot provide an answer that I feel requires enough understanding to understand.
@8VGVGB24yrs4Y
Increase, but I am concerned about immigrants being paid poorly and not having safe housing (as we saw was the case for temporary immigrant workers when there were many covid outbreaks in the insufficient housing offered by employers).
@8VCNMXY4yrs4Y
Routine federal check ups on businesses using this program to make sure they are not exploiting immigrant employees
@Steeviemac4yrs4Y
Increase, but only for occupations that are not filled by qualified Canadian citizens.
@8TXVXML4yrs4Y
Maintain, unless there is a huge need for specific jobs to be filled.
@8TX8MG34yrs4Y
It should be dependant on an audit of high skilled jobs, should only be used to create a robust economy. Not to cannibalize the prospects of Canadians
@8TV83B94yrs4Y
Increase but government should increase assistance for citizens to get these jobs also
@8TV3Z3Y4yrs4Y
Whoever working, whether an immigrant or citizen should be paid the same. And the most qualified people should be the ones with the job.
@8TJQYBB4yrs4Y
Only if they can prove there's nobody in Canada with the right qualifications and skills and work ethic to do the job
@shaelynj4yrs4Y
increase but have regulations so people don’t get underpaid
@8KM7QR54yrs4Y
We should base immigration on compassion, not corporate need.
@8HBYYNR5yrs5Y
I am satisfied with the current amount but there should be better regulation to stop companies from taking advatange of these workers.
@8VW35SB4yrs4Y
The TFW program should be completely revamped so that it isn’t used to suppress wages of Canadian citizens while taking advantage of desperate foreign workers.
@8VJ7P3X4yrs4Y
Increase Only if it doesn’t come at the cost of the citizens
@95YV2DZ3yrs3Y
Increase, but also increase the ability for less-skilled laborers to stay permanently if they wish.
@9ZK3JNS5mos5MO
Decrease and eliminate, we should not allow anyone into the country to take jobs unless they are doctors, firefighters or allied military providing aid in case of national emergency.
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.