Try the political quiz
@9ZJGHC4New Democratic DisagreementsCounter Argument5mos ago

This idea is based solely on the refusal of allowing trans people the right to exist, because trans people tend to have the same, if not more or the hormones that correlate with their gender identity, and, even if they had a slightly unfair advantage due to being trans, which they don't, the point of sports is to have genetic advantages and to take full advantage of them. Shaq wouldn't have been nearly as good as he was if he wasn't 7'1 300 pounds with the athleticism of a forward, LeBron wouldn't be in the goat conversation if he wasn't 6'9 who never ages, the entire point of sports is to have natural advantages and to use them to be better than your opponents, if you want to make separate categories/leagues for trans people, why not also people above a certain hight? Why not people with naturally higher testosterone levels? My point is that there is no logical reason to exclude trans people from sports and/or segregate them other than because you don't like them or aren't comfortable with their existence.

No replies yet…

Be the first to reply to this disagreement.

About this author

Learn more about the author that submitted this disagreement.

@9ZJGHC4

Last activeActivity7 discussionsInfluence1 engagementsEngagement bias100%Audience bias0%Active in
Counter Argument  3 Disagreements  3 Agreements  2 New question suggestions  1 Answers  1
PartyNew DemocraticLocationToronto, ON

More conversations

Join in on more popular conversations.

Active 7hrs ago

 @ISIDEWITH submitted…4mos4MO

US Jewish Groups Oppose Resettling Gaza

JTA — A number of major centrist and liberal American Jewish groups say they oppose the re-establishment of Israeli settlements in Gaza.The statements by some of the largest Jewish organizations in the country, made in response to press inquiries, come amid accusations that Israel has cleared out portions of northern Gaza, which Jerusalem has denied, and as far-right government ministers have called for resettling the Palestinian enclave. Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich and National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir have also repeatedly called for Israel to encourage Palestinians to leave Gaza, drawing condemnation from the Biden administration.For several American Jewish groups — including some that have vocally defended Israel’s prosecution of its war in Gaza against Hamas — the idea of Israeli settlements in Gaza is a non-starter. Groups opposed to the idea include the Jewish Federations of North America, the American Jewish Committee and the Anti-Defamation League. Also opposed are bodies representing the Reform and Conservative movements, which together can claim to represent the majority of American Jews.“The land between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea, indigenous to both Jews and Arabs, cannot be the exclusive domain of one people, but must be shared,” Jason Isaacson, AJC’s chief policy and political affairs officer, said. “Like the vast majority of Israelis, AJC believes that the re-establishment of Israeli settlements in Gaza, or a program of displacing Palestinians from Gaza or the West Bank, would be contrary to Israel’s interests.”Israel evacuated its Gaza settlements in 2005, and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has repeatedly ruled out the idea of re-establishing them after the war. But while most Israelis oppose the idea, more than a third — including 42% of Israeli Jews — support it, according to a recent poll by the Israel Democracy Institute. That includes nearly 60% of Israeli Jewish right-wingers, the current government’s voter base.“Ideas like settlement in Gaza are welcome, we need to remember that, in the end, that’s the biggest punishment for what they did to us on October 7,” Ben-Gvir said in an interview on Israeli radio this month, referencing the Hamas terror onslaught in southern Israel, in which some 1,200 people were slaughtered and 251 were seized as hostages, sparking the war in the enclave.

▲  159 replies