“Defund the police” is a slogan that supports divesting funds from police departments and reallocating them to non-policing forms of public safety and community support, such as social services, youth services, housing, education, healthcare and other community resources.
Narrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Discussions from these authors are shown:
Political party:
Voting for candidate:
Electoral District (2011):
Electoral District (2013):
@8PTVYLW4yrs4Y
No, police should instead be trained to respond in non-violent situations in order to mitigate police issues
@8Q2GXXR4yrs4Y
Agreed. The main counter-argument with this is that cops get paid highly and it wastes their time. If you consider those social workers are paid around 15k less per year than cops, and if this was implemented, cops would be paid 15k higher a year for their additional abilities to control violent mentally ill patients better and considering that social workers would have to call the cops anyways in that situation, you are actually saving money!
@8NS88GD4yrs4Y
No, give police departments should be given more training but some increased funding should still be given to community based programs.
@9SNLZ3S8mos8MO
The police should be replaced and led by uncorrupted and non racist individuals to avoid police brutality and racism, instead of playing to white supremacy.
@9LQKQVDNew Democratic12mos12MO
No, but more funding should go into training police and getting rid of racisms rooted in our police forces.
@9KYB6X71yr1Y
This should be a blended approach. Increase social programs but not at the cost of police, until the benefits have taken effect
@9FNVPXZ2yrs2Y
The government needs to smarten up and be financially responsible. This includes putting importance on both police and social programming with the goal of crime reduction. This isn't rocket science.
@9DQMRH42yrs2Y
Funding should be given to these programs, but not necessarily pulled from police budgets. However, police budgets should be subject to yearly audits.
@8QZS5YZ4yrs4Y
Remove some funding from police, put it back into communities. I wouldn’t say replace all police but definitely agree w having an unarmed person responding to non violent calls
@96KD6623yrs3Y
funding should increase so that police can be better train to deal with situations like mental health problems.
@96BJF8N3yrs3Y
Funding for police should be used for increased training to transition to public servants rather than enforcers
@9673VLG3yrs3Y
No, but money should be spent on regulating the police and training them thoroughly.
No but we should cut funding from some budgets to fund this instead.
@94Z3Z9R3yrs3Y
Yes, but have supported partners e.g social workers for non violent calls
@926XCDD3yrs3Y
some funding should be taken from police but not all funding
@8YP7H5M3yrs3Y
increase funding for police and social services, as well as strengthen police training on social problems
Continue the funding but limit it and redirect them for community needs.
@8YMXWD73yrs3Y
the police should get more funding fo better training especially in racial bias.
@8Y5K53S3yrs3Y
I feel that Funding should continue but the prerequisites for becoming a police officer should be more thorough.
@8XW2SFGNew Democratic3yrs3Y
funding should be increased to create teams on the force dedicated to mental health and crisis response
@8WXQL5S3yrs3Y
Yes for only certain topics
@8VWF8694yrs4Y
No, we still need police. But stricter punishments and background checks should be implemented on police for the public’s safety.
Yes, mental health advocates along side the police
@8VSQFG84yrs4Y
Train police in dealing with mental health issues when encountering the public
@8VQC4JCNew Democratic4yrs4Y
They should be reallocated to additional professionals to accompany the police for certain calls/emergencies
@8VN2DTD4yrs4Y
SOME funding should be redirected to other community services, yes.
@8VMFPYMNew Democratic4yrs4Y
Money needs to be allocating into better training, especially when it comes to mental health and learn non violent interventions
@8VL4GDB4yrs4Y
No but more funding should go to social and community based programs
@8VGYRYL4yrs4Y
Police should receive more training but the government should also be putting more money into social and community based programs.
@8VGYF6T4yrs4Y
Increase in police funding as well as Increases for mental health workers getting involved in certain situations.
@8VGVTB94yrs4Y
Increase funding and training for police departments around the country and also redirect some funding towards social and crisis based forces trained to deal with certain situations
@8VG9KRW4yrs4Y
No but change the policing system to handle non violent and violent people/situations better.
@8VDNFQB4yrs4Y
no, increase funding and training for de escalation tactics and address best practices for managing people in a mental health crisis
no, but their current budget should be adjusted to ensure the proper training is provided
@8VC4W684yrs4Y
Some funding should be taken out of the police budget and put towards better social programs
@8VBQCGH4yrs4Y
Needs to be a balance between local policing & funding social & community based programs
@8VBB3K64yrs4Y
Police should not be defunded but spending on social programs should be increased
Yes, replace police with ARMED community based responders for non-violent calls
@8V7CSFR4yrs4Y
Some, but I still think funding is important to our service members. Adequate training, and more support systems for non-violent crime and mental health is a middle ground I think could help.
@8V6LKS54yrs4Y
The programs that are not related to the police should be redirected to community based organizations
@8V6CDL5New Democratic4yrs4Y
They should lower funding for certain departments and increase funding to programs to solve underlying issues we need both police and programs
@8V585ZZ4yrs4Y
Redirect some funding but not all. Social workers do not get paid enough.
@8V563NZ4yrs4Y
Not familiar enough with practice
@8V2T4LC4yrs4Y
Yes, increase funding for other services so that police don't have to respond all the time
@8V2B4M44yrs4Y
Funding should be added/increased for social and community based programs, but not at the expense of the police.
@8TWGJ4BNew Democratic4yrs4Y
Yes, part of police funding should be allocated to social & community based programs based on regional requirements, supervised by non-police leadership.
@8TVXPCW4yrs4Y
There can be some reductions but as long as we are a neighbour of the USA we need an armed police force.
@8TV7MJ34yrs4Y
Both police AND social programs should receive an increase in funding and training as well as work together to create productive community solutions.
@8TTG8T74yrs4Y
Both are equally important. The police can help solve problems when it’s too late to turn back, but social resources can aid people in getting help and prevent them from resorting to crime in the first place.
I think we need police, but we should add funding towards proper mental health training
@8TJ4QSS4yrs4Y
redirect some funding to social and community based programs, but do not take away all funds from the police.
@8TJ4QBV4yrs4Y
Yes, but still maintain the police force
@8THYZ364yrs4Y
I personally have no stance on this.
@8THMB53New Democratic4yrs4Y
@8TH624Q4yrs4Y
it depends if it is a high crime rate neighborhood then there should be more funding but if it is a community with less crime then I think there should be an unarmed community base to respond to no violent crimes.
@8TGSHWT4yrs4Y
More funding should be allocated do proper mental health support can be used but not all finding
@8T7LKKF4yrs4Y
Amalgamate the services so that police have the same training as mental health officials. Because at the same time if it’s a serious issue the non-armed mental health people could be hurt/killed. Plus extensive background checks for police officers. (Social media, etc to monitor for racist and destructive behaviour)
@8T5NZR64yrs4Y
Make the police also have a psychology background/education. To better equip them to descalate the situation.
@8T2DR8X4yrs4Y
I think that it should be split more evenly, because both programs are important
@8SY2DFF4yrs4Y
Extra funding should be directed to the police to combine police with teams of social workers and nurses. Community outreach to help find a treatment stream for persons suffering from mental health disorders
Only partially. There are benefits to more social and community programs and less police, but not no police.
@8SWN3524yrs4Y
increase funding for police to get better training and smarter cops
@8STPTP9New Democratic4yrs4Y
Divided equally between the two
@8SSLDBW4yrs4Y
fund the police less but still keep them and fund the social services more
@8SPB7XM4yrs4Y
funding should be given out equally
@8SN9TV44yrs4Y
Decrease budget ,by 20 % to social programs in the communityp
@8SJ5BDV4yrs4Y
No, instead the funding should be distributed better, to allow for an improvement in the training of police officers.
@8SFXDQY4yrs4Y
Yes, the police system needs to be restructured to better fit different situations
@8SD9CD4New Democratic4yrs4Y
funding to be slightly reduced from police departments and re directed to other departments such as education
@8SCLH964yrs4Y
@8S42FF54yrs4Y
I believe the police should get what ever funding they need to retrain and rework their system from stopping fight/crimes to preventing and deescalating.
@8RG6SG34yrs4Y
I feel that police need more training and testing. But also they should be more restricted on thier funds.
@8R9WRZ24yrs4Y
Yes, but maintain some funding for police as well as increase training.
@8R8MD884yrs4Y
Keep funding well balanced.
Increase training, stricter surveillance on police officers to ensure no breach in protocol.
@8R38BSK4yrs4Y
I think that the funding should go to making police training stricter to make sure they are fair and want to actually help people.
@8QY69VQ4yrs4Y
I think that the money should be put towards harder testing to make sure that police or more properly selected and we'll carefully selected .
@8QY5FQV4yrs4Y
No, it's good as it is right now
@8QSYPQG4yrs4Y
Make sure that police are trained properly and not to immediately react with violence and instead find a peaceful solution, fire the bad ones
@8QKLPWWNew Democratic4yrs4Y
Increase funding for psychological departments in the police.
@8QFCQGTNew Democratic4yrs4Y
No, police should recieve more funding to use on better training and community initiatives.
@8QF2V554yrs4Y
No, it should be it should be put towards better and longer more effective training for police
@8Q95CT54yrs4Y
Overhaul of the police system and training.
@8PRXNBD4yrs4Y
Increase funding for police officers to gain new knowledge and training.
@8PM82LC4yrs4Y
Some of the police's funding should be.
Direct some funding to allow certain services that are not appropriate for police to deal with.
@8PKD9TD4yrs4Y
Yes , reduce police funding in areas that don't need it and redirect it
@8PK9JTC4yrs4Y
No, work for police reform
it should go towards training them to be better in the ways that they dont harm people who dont deserve it
@8PDRZ784yrs4Y
Yes but as long as good officers are not getting fired as a result of less funding.
@8PDF4534yrs4Y
i think this is a more complicated question as we need protection but there is no way to be sure if said protection will treat everyone fairly as a lot of officers abuse their power
@9CNHY4F2yrs2Y
I think funding to both the local police and social and community based programs are as equally important
@9B4Z8RW2yrs2Y
Some of it should but not a total redirection
@99VCF4WNew Democratic2yrs2Y
I believe police need more training, less funding.
@999RKPG2yrs2Y
No, increase funding to social and community based programs but keeping funding for local police departments
@98RK2XD2yrs2Y
More funding for social and community based programs while supporting local police
@95XYRB83yrs3Y
Cooperation between these two sectors and more funding directed towards social and community support. Reducing funding for the police helps no one.
@923XY2R3yrs3Y
Both sides of the coin should have enough funding to cover their needs.
@8YVJYS43yrs3Y
Yes, having police is important but I believe funding in that department can be allocated in social and community-based programs.
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.