“Defund the police” is a slogan that supports divesting funds from police departments and reallocating them to non-policing forms of public safety and community support, such as social services, youth services, housing, education, healthcare and other community resources.
Narrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Discussions from these authors are shown:
Political party:
Voting for candidate:
Electoral District (2011):
Electoral District (2013):
@8PTVYLW4yrs4Y
No, police should instead be trained to respond in non-violent situations in order to mitigate police issues
@8Q2GXXR4yrs4Y
Agreed. The main counter-argument with this is that cops get paid highly and it wastes their time. If you consider those social workers are paid around 15k less per year than cops, and if this was implemented, cops would be paid 15k higher a year for their additional abilities to control violent mentally ill patients better and considering that social workers would have to call the cops anyways in that situation, you are actually saving money!
@8NS88GD4yrs4Y
No, give police departments should be given more training but some increased funding should still be given to community based programs.
Yes, redirect SOME funding toward better social programs for non-violent offences.
@8C8JYY85yrs5Y
No but police need specialized training in mental health and more training in non-leathal force
@8H6JLM35yrs5Y
Yes, reduce the police budget and allocate police evenly across the city. Put funds into stopping sex trafficking, gun violence, etc. Stop over policing some areas over others.
@9ZDD7FV5mos5MO
No, it shouldn't be taken from the police departments. But definitely increase funding through other means.
@9YNBJYHNew Democratic5mos5MO
Yes and no, increase funding for local police departments to educate them but also create social and community-based programs that can deal with different types of situations.
@9W74WNB6mos6MO
Allocate existing funding and resources towards educating officers on systemic racism inherent to the police system with the goal to reduce police brutality and racial profiling.
Direct more funds towards social and community-based programs - why does it have to come from the police fund? Question seems irrelevant and pointed.
@9TXXY437mos7MO
Funding should be put into training for RCMP who respond to mental health and wellness checks. They need to learn how to deescalate situations without the use of anything but words.
@9SNLZ3S8mos8MO
The police should be replaced and led by uncorrupted and non racist individuals to avoid police brutality and racism, instead of playing to white supremacy.
It totally depends on the jurisdiction in question. Allocating funding to social programs matters, it can come from police budgets, but I don’t associate them closely.
@9RBWNKL9mos9MO
A nuanced approach looking for the right balance would be better than putting one against the other.
@9KYB6X71yr1Y
This should be a blended approach. Increase social programs but not at the cost of police, until the benefits have taken effect
@9HS37CY1yr1Y
Maybe just let an accountant comb through the police budget without threat of livelihood being compromised. I’m sure there’s plenty of fat to cut.
Policy decisions should be data-based on whether more social services or more police would benefit a given district/
I think that more funding should go towards getting proper training for officers, especially psychological training because you never know when you will encounter someone in a crisis.
@9G8F9LCNew Democratic2yrs2Y
no, current funding should be used for teaching about mental health issues in the people as well as de-escalating situations and non-violent tactics
@9FNVPXZ2yrs2Y
The government needs to smarten up and be financially responsible. This includes putting importance on both police and social programming with the goal of crime reduction. This isn't rocket science.
@8QGN3DX4yrs4Y
Yes, however we still need armed police officers. They need to go through more training as well as adding more social and community based programs
@8QZS5YZ4yrs4Y
Remove some funding from police, put it back into communities. I wouldn’t say replace all police but definitely agree w having an unarmed person responding to non violent calls
@9CLF8FB2yrs2Y
I think that we should have funding for programs for at risk youth but, we should have better training for high crime areas.
@96DRDYW3yrs3Y
Depends on the area but yes cut some of their funding.
@96BJF8N3yrs3Y
Funding for police should be used for increased training to transition to public servants rather than enforcers
@9673VLG3yrs3Y
No, but money should be spent on regulating the police and training them thoroughly.
@95HLG9T3yrs3Y
do not cut the funding for police but create less harmful responders for non violent calls
@955L8YL3yrs3Y
Police are needed to prevent chaos, but training and social community based programs are also needed. An interdisceplinary approach is viable when training and funding is properly assigned.
@94FZFL63yrs3Y
keep it the same and find other funds for community based programs as well.
@9438Y3Y3yrs3Y
No, Increase training for police officers for social work
They should each be their own thing
@93G3LSP3yrs3Y
Police funding should remain healthy while still dispersing a helpful and fair amount of money to social and community-based programs.
@937LYXM3yrs3Y
@92QYHRH3yrs3Y
Yes, but with limited, not no, spending
@929JF7B3yrs3Y
No, instead create new positions for mental health and crisis counseling experts to assist in non-violent calls
@927WQGJ3yrs3Y
No, funding should be increased to include alternative response methods. In GB and other countries, first responders don't have guns. Several teams intervene before armed response. And increase funding to community programs like mental health initiatives and youth counselling as prevention.
@926XCDD3yrs3Y
some funding should be taken from police but not all funding
@926M3CR3yrs3Y
No, but increase required police training and accountability
@8Z3CLLL3yrs3Y
It should split but more focused on the community
@8YX8TTP3yrs3Y
Don’t really know honestly
Continue the funding but limit it and redirect them for community needs.
@8YMXWD73yrs3Y
the police should get more funding fo better training especially in racial bias.
@8YLRG4S3yrs3Y
Yes, but with the hope that the police departments train in a social work course.
@8XX9M3F3yrs3Y
Better training for police and use of community bases programs
@8XMV3KJ3yrs3Y
they should be trained on how to respect
@8WXQL5S3yrs3Y
Yes for only certain topics
@8VX7HSS4yrs4Y
some of the funding should go to social and community based programs
@8VWQGM74yrs4Y
No, redirect funding in police to train for de-escalation and other types of training
@8VVYWJK4yrs4Y
Some funding should be directed to unarmed community based responders
@8VVYHX34yrs4Y
Evaluate and relocate funds after a national audit.
@8VVVQS44yrs4Y
Increase or maintain funding and significantly increase training, impose stricter oversight and punishment, and increase mandatory mental health evaluations and treatment forpolice.
@8VTVNTXNew Democratic4yrs4Y
More education and more screening
Yes, mental health advocates along side the police
@8VS85NMNew Democratic4yrs4Y
Reallocate funding for more desecalation training and mental health training
@8VRZY3V4yrs4Y
Police need more comprehensive training AND we need more money for social programs.
@8VRQPFL4yrs4Y
No.. just fix the broken mental healthcare system.
@8VRN5Q84yrs4Y
No, maintain current funding
@8VRLD9S4yrs4Y
Increase funding to help officers be better through education and sensitivity training
@8VRH67T4yrs4Y
Change finding allocation: more to training and far far less to arming them and new vehicles and the like. Leftover funds towards community based responders
@8VR36ZS4yrs4Y
We still need police officers in the world no matter how hard we try and push them away. We just need a stronger approach on who to hire and training specific to understand their job and what they can and can’t do. Just because you have a badge doesn’t mean you win.
@8VQCN52New Democratic4yrs4Y
Social and community based programs should be apart of local police departments
@8VP6D8M4yrs4Y
Put more funding in mental health approaches and training for police officers
@8VN2DTD4yrs4Y
SOME funding should be redirected to other community services, yes.
@8VMX5VH4yrs4Y
No, but should invest in social programs that work with police
@8VMFPYMNew Democratic4yrs4Y
Money needs to be allocating into better training, especially when it comes to mental health and learn non violent interventions
@8VLRB844yrs4Y
Not fully redirected, but more money should be going to community, but also still some going to police
@8VLMNLQ4yrs4Y
Funding shouldn’t be taken away from police but more funding should be put in place for community based programs
@8VLCT8R4yrs4Y
Absolutely, the police are a joke. They do nothing to help and just cause anxiety. We need more social programming.
@8VL4GDB4yrs4Y
No but more funding should go to social and community based programs
@8VKNBZTConservative4yrs4Y
Keep police, increase funding to social support systems
@8VK7JBB4yrs4Y
No, funding for police should include de-esclation, and a focus on mental stress health
@8VK3CFK4yrs4Y
The justice system needs to be overhauled to better suit the values of our society of today for all people. There needs to be a partnership between police and social resources to address the calls coming in and resolve them safely.
@8VHL7RY4yrs4Y
fund the police so they can stop being racist
It should be split appropriately between both. More funding for social and economic programs could mean less crime
@8VGYRYL4yrs4Y
Police should receive more training but the government should also be putting more money into social and community based programs.
@8VGVTB94yrs4Y
Increase funding and training for police departments around the country and also redirect some funding towards social and crisis based forces trained to deal with certain situations
@8VG9KRW4yrs4Y
No but change the policing system to handle non violent and violent people/situations better.
@8VDNFQB4yrs4Y
no, increase funding and training for de escalation tactics and address best practices for managing people in a mental health crisis
@8VDKY7WLibertarian4yrs4Y
police should have access to more training and social workers and addiction counsellors should be on site if needed.
@8VC4W684yrs4Y
Some funding should be taken out of the police budget and put towards better social programs
@8VBY7CMConservative4yrs4Y
Funding should be increased fro police departments in higher crime rate communities. But social and community based programs should also get more funding
@8VBB3K64yrs4Y
Police should not be defunded but spending on social programs should be increased
Yes, replace police with ARMED community based responders for non-violent calls
@8V9DRKD4yrs4Y
Add more mental health services in conjunction with the police.
@8V87Q6C4yrs4Y
Yes up to a certain amount
I believe the police are an important staple in community safety, however i believe that SOME of their funding should be funneled into social and community initiatives.
@8V7CSFR4yrs4Y
Some, but I still think funding is important to our service members. Adequate training, and more support systems for non-violent crime and mental health is a middle ground I think could help.
@8V6YCPY4yrs4Y
Yes, add more mental health and social service workers to their teams
@8V6CDL5New Democratic4yrs4Y
They should lower funding for certain departments and increase funding to programs to solve underlying issues we need both police and programs
@8V2N7GZ4yrs4Y
Stop putting caps on police and let them do their job to ACTUALLY serve and protect.
@8TYX9XF4yrs4Y
More funding should be sent to community based programs but also towards training the police
@8TYLQ6VConservative4yrs4Y
Fund the police but also have a mental health unit or medical persons to be involved
@8TWQGZF4yrs4Y
Maintain their funding but divert wellness checks and suicide threats to mental health workers to relieve some workload on the officers.
@8TWNDBF4yrs4Y
Increase funding for de-escalation police practices and social programs, maintain salaries for police officers as is
No, police should not be abolished, but funding for social and community based programs should be increased, and police should be trained to better respond/be vetted more before being hired.
@8TV8RPC4yrs4Y
Integrate social programs and medical staff with local police for relevant calls (eg. psych calls, ODs)
@8TTL3QB4yrs4Y
Yes, we should Reform our police system
@8TPCHP44yrs4Y
Do not decrease police funding but also raise social program funding
@8TMP66V4yrs4Y
both should be supported
I think we need police, but we should add funding towards proper mental health training
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.