Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Province/Territory:
@4P29LQ64yrs4Y
Let's use common sense here, who is out of work? Have they been here longer than the guy that has the current job? Then take him out and put the guy who was in this country the longest in that place, A) he's done more for the country B) we need to start worrying more about the people we have in this country than the ones from other countries.
@9WBRK8D1mo1MO
Decrease except where needs are high such as Doctors trained to the same or better standard as Canada.
@9TNBDV82mos2MO
Decrease, and the companies applying should be obligated to train local workers to eventually take over after the temporary position.
@9MJ379FConservative6mos6MO
people can work wherever they want it doesn’t matter who or what you are. at the end of the day we’re all people
@9LJVNVS7mos7MO
They shouldn't bother creating temporary work visas. It's either they are a citizen or not a citizen, because that most workers goals anyways in this program.
@9FJSRV91yr1Y
Maintain as much as possible while still directing said workers to industries with a shortage of Canadian workers
@9F7DNYY1yr1Y
Increase, but only for industries with critical shortages of workers (such as the healthcare system)
@9F5KMPV1yr1Y
Train more Canadians and prioritize Canadians when hiring. Do more to address the worker shortage within Canada using Canadians but use foreign temporary workers if necessary.
@9D4R2DY1yr1Y
Neither, current temporary foreign workers should be offered permanent residence and potential for citizenship
@9QZCYDN4mos4MO
Probably keep it the same, maybe increase it but only slightly. I also think work Visa programs should be more common and replace some of the temporary foreign worker program
@9QX648Q 4mos4MO
Neither, immediately extend permanent resident status to all non-status and temporary status workers in Canada
@9Q6HHH75mos5MO
No, but increase regulations on the businesses that hire temporary workers to insure wages are not depressed and temporary workers receive adequate wages.
@9K3DVX49mos9MO
Increase, could form a better bond to the people of foreign countries resulting in better variety of contacts which could lead to greater supply for trade
@9JC6BKV10mos10MO
Decrease the minimum wage and remove some social programs to incentivise unemployed Canadians to fill these roles; alternatively subsidize automation in these industries to replace the labour.
@9GZYG4J1yr1Y
Regardless, improving immigration rules, citizenship test, border control and accepting anyone who's not a criminal or a national threat, also imposing no limit amount of immigrants or legal residents would make this question irrelevant.
@9GYSNHD1yr1Y
Decrease, we need to start worrying more about the people we have in this country than the ones from other countries.
@9FPG8CX1yr1Y
Decrease slightly, again the problem is housing.
easy for said workers to be exploited, so i suppose heavy heavy regulations and worker rights for the employers
@tofutofu4yrs4Y
Temporary foreign workers should only be used for industries with a shortage of Canadian workers. However, these industries should gain promotion within the country to encourage more Canadian citizens to get involved in these industries. As always, when temporary foreign workers are brought in to work, they deserve the same wage and rights, and conditions while they're working as a Canadian citizen would receive. Their work and time needs to be valued.
@9653HWJ2yrs2Y
Increase, but only for industries with a shortage of Canadian workers.
@95K5YQG2yrs2Y
It's obviously needed, as these jobs are jobs that many Canadians wouldn't want to do as they are hard jobs that are long hours, but I would also say that we need to treat them with respect, and we can't just let them be at the whim of the agricultural owners as well. I would say keep the system as it is, but we also can't ignore the problems with it, nor the growing demand of Canadian produce that is needed around the world right now, especially with the war in Ukraine.
@94CXG6G2yrs2Y
No foreign workers should be allowed in Canada.
@93WL6VF2yrs2Y
Canadian workers in industries such as farms could fill the jobs that are currently available in Canada on a larger business. Greed should not be incentivized, plenty of young people could use these opportunities as stepping stones into the work place that are Canadian citizens.
@8Z87ZRQ3yrs3Y
No more foreign workers, provide jobs for your own.
@8XZNFFC3yrs3Y
Regardless, the government should not be involved in this matter.
End allowing temporary foreign workers into Canada, period. There are plenty of able body, able minded Canadians not working.
Monitor to allow to react to needs.
@8VC7N6SConservative3yrs3Y
Continue to monitor job demand by industry and allow addition work visas accordingly
Depends on our current needs
@8V8L4X33yrs3Y
Decrease, this system is being abused.
@8TYWNDPNew Democratic3yrs3Y
Considered individual cases, the need and if there are enough Canadian workers to fill positions
@8TRPMHX3yrs3Y
I am unsure at this moment/ don’t have enough information to formulate an opinion
@8TLH2TQ3yrs3Y
Increase, and offer easy pathways to citizenship if the worker is interested in permanently relocating to Canada
No they should automatically be able to become Canadian citizens
Maintain the current amount for industries without a shortage, and increase only for industries with a shortage of canadian workers.
@8SM79NB4yrs4Y
Because of Covid they should decrease who comes into Canada.
@8S73DY84yrs4Y
listen to economists on this subject
@8S69HSH4yrs4Y
Decrease, we should invest in Canadians who are in the unemployment field.
Allow where it is necessary. Where is our tax money being allocated. We should determine the highest rate of tax our citizens are expected to provide for people that are new to this country. It's not fair for people that have been contributing for 30+ years to our government to be taken advantage of by people that have just moved here and refuse to work.
@8PMSYCP4yrs4Y
allow for industries with a shortage of Canadian workers only
@8PJF9PZ4yrs4Y
The amount should be determined by the unemployment level experienced at the time. Putting Canadians to work first should be the priority
@8PFW692Rhinoceros4yrs4Y
Regardless, the temporary foreign workers need to be better protected. Employers mistreat them and threaten to deport them if they report the mistreatment. They need to be aware of their rights and have options if their employers are abusive. This information and contact people need to be available in their langague.
@8P5W5TT4yrs4Y
asses the need for temporary workers on a fiscal basis
@8P3F3JT4yrs4Y
Eliminate, and end the temporary foreign worker program.
@8NWWHM34yrs4Y
Canada should have an agreement with closely allied countries (United States, Australia, Mexico) to allow workers to freely work in each country.
@8J9KWCY4yrs4Y
Provide incentives for people within Canada to vie for these jobs first.
@8CW6SXRNew Democratic4yrs4Y
Decrease, companies are currently taking advantage of this program to suppress wages.
@9978ZGM2yrs2Y
Neither, Temporary foreign workers should make the same wages as citizens doing the same job, and be given a path to citizenship or permanent residency
@996HZ642yrs2Y
I wouldn't have the faintest idea.
@98T25SZ2yrs2Y
I am ok with current amount
@98B6SV52yrs2Y
Temporary worker should be only allowed if they want citizenship, and stay in the country.
@988GXLK2yrs2Y
Increase, but only workers with post-secondary education
@8VMRWH83yrs3Y
The level should be dependant on the need
@8VK9FD53yrs3Y
increased, if they are skilled workers
@8V94HH43yrs3Y
Increase, not enough temporary workers for agriculture production
@Kerrnel3yrs3Y
We should be educating our population that work role does not equal value, and incentivize Canadians to take jobs that used to be viewed as "beneath them"
@8TZ65QC3yrs3Y
Decrease or increase as needed
@95VJTPZ2yrs2Y
They should be treated as citizens with medical. And companies found abusing them should be charged.
@8TQTW27New Democratic3yrs3Y
Temporary foreign workers should make the same wages as citizens doing the same job, and be given a path to citizenship or permanent residency
@8WFRGBH3yrs3Y
Until the citizen of the land can’t put numbers allowed foreigners to work
@8VW3N8D3yrs3Y
@8VRFTSW3yrs3Y
Depends based on work needed
@8TGZRLY3yrs3Y
Increase, but make standards for living, access to healthcare, etc.
@8YLNZTD3yrs3Y
Depends on the work being done.
@8WTKT243yrs3Y
Increase for immigrants and non immigrants
@8QZL5HTConservative4yrs4Y
Depends on the economy and Canada's current unemployment rate at that time.
@8PP8HST4yrs4Y
Increase, because despite what some claim immigration actually helps our economy. But the Canadian government needs to establish a national identity that all Canadians can share to prevent tribalism among our various cultures.
@8DHQ3QG4yrs4Y
Increase, as long as it does not take jobs away from Canadian residents
@3CJWWC94yrs4Y
Temporary foreign works numbers should be based on non availability of Canadian worker. foreign workers should be taxed, have to supply their own medical insurance before entering Canada and make sure their children are attending school or being homeschooled.
@3CJVQPH4yrs4Y
If there is a Canadian qualified for the job it goes to them first. If no Canadian is qualified a temporary foreign worker is allowed.
@3CJNKX54yrs4Y
Make the system fairer and less arbitrary. It is a disaster now and Service Canada needs to be more accountable and reasonable. It is better to have temporary foreign workers come here to work and then give the successful ones a chance at permanent residence than to try to assess skilled workers who haven't even been to Canada yet. The Canada Experience Class was a good program. Now it is being mutilated and changed to make it less appealing to foreign students. Foreign students are good for the economy and immigration program. Students who learn here and then work here will make the best immigrants. At eth same time, we benefit economically from their spending while here.
@3CJKXQP4yrs4Y
I am an immigrant, I exactly know why they need to work here, it's for the money. They need it for their family back at their country. To stay the same what it used to be would be a big help for them and for their families :)
@3CJJBVR4yrs4Y
Businesses were taking advantage of the FWP. Overhaul and reinstate it
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.