Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Discussions from these authors are shown:
Province/Territory:
@B4KJ9LB1wk1W
Quebec is every bit as much of a part of the country of Canada, as any of the other provinces and territories. The federal government needs to work with them, and help to deal with their specific needs as a part of Canada.
@B29GCD73mos3MO
No, but if a referendum succeded, Quebec would have to take its fair share of debt and return all military equipment to Canada.
@B2L42TM3mos3MO
No Canada was found by three nations (first nations, English and French) it is our identity without Quebec we are no longer Canada
@9TYSP557mos7MO
No and if they seperate they should only get what we origanlly gave them a small strip along the st lawrence river.
@9NW5MPL10mos10MO
Let them go They complain much Pull out federal property such as military hardware and day good bye
@9QVHJ3B9mos9MO
Quebec will never be the same without Canada and vice-versa. We need to work on equality between French and English Canadians.
@9KTFCM71yr1Y
Let the citizens of Quebec vote on it. It would be an astoundingly stupid move on their part, though.
@9JZV4G6Conservative1yr1Y
Goodbye! Take your debt with you, AND remember that removes your access to our military and you lose a huge chunk of your land.
@9JWWFBK1yr1Y
Quebec citizens should make that decision, however the terms of separation should be clear beforehand so they are making an informed decision.
Yes, but it has to be voted on and confirmed that Quebec gan grow and survive long-term. They also have to be willing to take on their own debt.
@9DVZ2NF2yrs2Y
No, but it could be granted more autonomy from the government and country.
@9DRYGB6 2yrs2Y
No, because it sets a blockade to the Atlantic provinces.
Land back - indigenous sovereignty first
@8ZT5SNW3yrs3Y
No, it would actually harm many French communities
@8ZR6F7T3yrs3Y
They should have to vote with 51% agreeing to leave Canada. They would have to pay for their share of the debt, pay for any buildings or land currently owned by the federal government, and pay market costs for the houses of anyone who wishes to move (or first and last month rent and moving expenses of anyone wishing to leave, before separation. They would also have to implement their own currency.
@8ZPB5Y43yrs3Y
Not properly informed on topic
@8Z85DBV3yrs3Y
They should not have a political party at the federal level.
@8WZT74J3yrs3Y
As long as they take their share of the debt and have no economic or military ties to Canada
@8VW29Z54yrs4Y
No, diversity is a strength, not a problem.
@8VTCRZC4yrs4Y
It won’t solve their problems and would make things more difficult for them. If they leave, they should not get any benefits to being in close proximity to this country. If they leave, they will make things harder for the East coast which isn’t good (since they thrive on tourism and that would likely make tourism harder) I don’t think it’s necessary for them and instead they should try to enjoy being apart of Canada and lessen their focus on leaving
@8VT966B4yrs4Y
yes but they run as their own country with zero funding/aid and take their share of debt
@8V6CPT24yrs4Y
The question of Quebec independence should be voted on by Quebecers and by the rest of Canada, as it will affect the entire country. A two-third majority should be required for a vote to pass.
@8V5WF4K4yrs4Y
If they take on their share of the national debt, and relinquish all military & economic support, yes. Let them become their own country IF they are willing to handle all that entails.
@Canadian14yrs4Y
Absolutely NOT. Quebec is a part of Canada, period. No political party should exist that is attempting to sever it from Canada. This is ridiculous really, seeing as our elections are for Canada as a nation. They need to accept that they are forever Canadian. (I was born there btw)
@8TVBXKH4yrs4Y
Yes, but only with vast majority voting in favour, and with the cutting of all economic, military, health care support, etc
@8TTCLGB4yrs4Y
if seperatists want to leave let them, if not we should fight them for qubec, and stop putting up with this. and they simply cannot have a federal seperation party.
@97BRZXP2yrs2Y
last i checked legally their is no mechanism in the canadian constitution for separation, but if they must have it high turn out (80-90%) election with over 60% voting yes and no questions asked. otherwise the complaint of separatists always leaves out other french canadian communities of canada ignoring them in a self centered bid for power and relevance
@937ZKJ53yrs3Y
Yes. Pay their debt first and then they are cut off completely from us. No aid No anything from us.
@8V3CSNR4yrs4Y
Yes but take their portion of the debt and cut all ties.
@8TZ48GP4yrs4Y
Quebec is in the middle of multiple provinces and therefor they technically can not be their own country or leave Canada properly.
@9BJ887SNew Democratic2yrs2Y
No, but do allow more freedom to express their culture and establish individuality from the predominantly English sections of Canada.
@8VBS9WB4yrs4Y
If they don't want to be Canadian then leave the country
@8VBS2FBConservative4yrs4Y
No. If they don't like Canada they should leave
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.
