Should Canadian citizens be allowed to save or invest their money in offshore bank accounts?
An offshore (or foreign) bank account is a bank account you have outside of your country of residence. The benefits of an offshore bank account include tax reduction, privacy, currency diversification, asset protection from lawsuits, and reducing your political risk. In April 2016, Wikileaks released 11.5 million confidential documents, known as the Panama Papers, which provided detailed information on 214,000 offshore companies serviced by the Panamanian Law Firm, Mossack Fonesca. The document exposed how world leaders and wealthy individuals hide money in secret offshore tax shelters. The…
Read moreNarrow down the conversation to these participants:
Province/Territory:
@B4PPBZN2wks2W
The state should have less control over and less information about what an induvidual citizen does with their money.
@B4ND9T9Conservative3wks3W
With the threat of the Liberal government (or any government) using its power to freeze individuals' banking accounts, and in the limitations of the Canadian stock market, all citizens should have the right to invest money outside of Canada for safekeeping.
@B395BGK2mos2MO
its a person's money, and the goverment shouldn't have a say about any thing a person does with their money
@9QZCYDN10mos10MO
Yes, but it must be a trusted offshore bank and all income must be reported in order to avoid loopholes by corporations and the wealthy
@9K58RGL1yr1Y
Yes, long as the income is reported and taxes are paid accordingly. Corporations and businesses should not be able to do so to evade taxes or audits of their financial dealings.
@9RBTBFT9mos9MO
Yes, but there should be penalties and the income should be taxed at a higher rate than income earned from Canadian investments.
@9K6M4541yr1Y
Only for the lower class people, rich people depend but some should be good as long as they're not over millionaries or billionaries and as such.
@9FQ2ZJY2yrs2Y
Yes, as long as it is properly reported and taxed and only when existing loopholes are effectively closed
@9FM9QN92yrs2Y
Yes, only if the intention/cause is acceptable.
@9F2VYKP2yrs2Y
i don't have an opinion on this.
@9F5KMPV2yrs2Y
No, scummy rich people do it to evade taxes.
@937LMWD3yrs3Y
yes, why does it matter to Canada where money is located, as long as when it was earned taxes were payed on it.
@8ZSJL5B3yrs3Y
No, neither should corporations and business organizations and too many wealthy citizens are abusing loopholes in offshore banking laws to evade taxes.
@8XDRVQT3yrs3Y
Yes, but should be decentivized from doing so
@8VVWQC74yrs4Y
If the original income is taxed what difference does it make
@8VHLQFB4yrs4Y
Doesn't really matter unless it's in a bank where they can hide their money either because of criminal activity or to avoid paying taxes. It would only matter if we had a public bank.
@8VH4ZRZ4yrs4Y
Yes, but only if you have dual citizenship
@8VH2TZWConservative4yrs4Y
Yes, but it has to be properly reported and enforced. Penalties for improper use or declaration should be extremely heavy. Something like forfeiture of 50% of the value of the off shore account, 25% to be donated to the provincial healthcare system of their choice and the remaining 25% can be released.
@8VH22SV4yrs4Y
No neither should government officials or corporations or businesses
@8VGW5K44yrs4Y
Yes, to a limited amount
@8VFM77J4yrs4Y
They should be able to as far as they disclose all the income earned from that money.
@8VFD2CZ4yrs4Y
Yes but make sure it’s not corrupt
Yes, for private citizens as long as we close loopholes that assist in tax evasion. No for corporations
@8V95QN24yrs4Y
No, we should ban this practice for corporations, business organizations and people and too many wealthy people are abusing loopholes in offshore bank accounts to evade taxes
@8V4C6JN4yrs4Y
My stance is no, but I’d be worried about wealth leaving the country with such restrictions which would be damaging.
@8TWZJFZ4yrs4Y
Yes for citizen as long as offshore income is reported and considered, so that they can't qualify for benefits if they don't actually need them and corporations and business organizations should NOT be able to save or invest their money in offshore bank accounts.
@8TN4GLW4yrs4Y
Yes, and saving and investing money in offshore bank accounts should be made easier as doing so wouldn’t be necessary if taxes were decreased significantly.
@8RJTBVG4yrs4Y
Yes, but only in safe countries such as the US and UK, and monitor it so that it is not abused by the wealthy.
@8R9YBHV4yrs4Y
Yes but there should be bonuses to moving the money back into Canada for investments and higher taxes when the money is removed from investments without being put into canadian investment
@oscitare4yrs4Y
Yes, as long as offshore income is reported, but don’t allow corporations and business organizations
@8QTX67R4yrs4Y
Yes, as long as there are regulations so this is not abused
@8PYXCGL4yrs4Y
Depends on what their net worth is, if not a millionaire or billionaire, yes, but if you are making more than $1,000,000, absolutely not.
@8PK8YRR4yrs4Y
Yes, if they have dual citizenship in that country
@8NZWYH64yrs4Y
No too many rich people are abusing loopholes in offshore banking laws to evade taxes. Laws should be implemented for those that abuse these loopholes to charge them with tax evasion and fine them accordingly, we may not like to pay taxes but it’s a civic responsibility.
@8NWJ3SPLibertarian4yrs4Y
Yes, as long as offshore income is reported, however corporations and business organizations should not.
@8L67S2V5yrs5Y
It doesnt really matter to me
@8D4X4PW5yrs5Y
Yes, and report it and increase taxes on those that do to 75%
@8CCZXDP5yrs5Y
Money that is earned offshore can be in offshore accounts. After tax is paid on Canadian earned money it can be moved offshore. There needs to be valid reports done on this to ensure no tax evasion is present.
@9C63S732yrs2Y
Their money, not my problem.
@9BJY9J42yrs2Y
Yes, but for only low income familles
@98WXKGQ2yrs2Y
Yes, but only citizens under a certain income threshold in order to prevent wealthy elites from abusing tax loopholes or taking advantage of tax shelters.
@98PQTLX2yrs2Y
Yes, as long as the offshore bank income is reported then it should be fine
@94DW2ZY3yrs3Y
Yes, but a wealth tax should be put in place to account for using loopholes
@942M3263yrs3Y
No, criminalize this practice and neither should corporations or business organizations.
@93TM7X63yrs3Y
No, make this illegal and establish a watchdog ageny to ensure compliance, all offshore income will be frozen and sent back to Canada for taxing.
@92MWQCF3yrs3Y
Yes, but only foreign money
@98S47972yrs2Y
Yes, as long as there are precautions in place to stop people from abusing loopholes in offshore banking laws to evade taxes
@8P54FKL4yrs4Y
Taxation in any form is theft
@kuyugomodiLiberal5yrs5Y
Yes the government should be all up in our money like they are
@8PJHVJN4yrs4Y
Yes, as long as it is reported but I will tax you by 7.5% more.
@lucasnat0r4yrs4Y
Yes but they should be incentivized to invest in the country they live in.
@8PD23XN4yrs4Y
Yes, but they should have to declare it and pay a fee on all offshore money
Only in freer part of the world. Not communist or fascist states.
@8GR8N5C5yrs5Y
I feel that I do not have enough information to agree or disagree
@8F3TJ7L5yrs5Y
Yes, and that income should be taxed at the difference between the country's rate and the U.S. rate, encouraging U.S. citizens to just keep the money here because it won't decrease tax burden.
@7W3SBDC4yrs4Y
Yes, but strict laws and stiff penalties for failure to report.
@7KCBJ6J5yrs5Y
No, both wealthy citizens and corporations are abusing loopholes to evade taxes.
@6ZS8SV45yrs5Y
No, unless they also hold citizenship in said country.
@DsInferno5yrs5Y
Yes, but because the wealthy will always find loopholes in the system increase tax audits for people in the highest tax bracket
@IINXMP4yrs4Y
Yes, as long as tax dollars are still paid.
@8H4DF7B4yrs4Y
Yes if the income is reported and loopholes are eliminated.
@92YHQCV3yrs3Y
No, and neither should corporations and business organizations because too many wealthy citizens are abusing loopholes in offshore banking laws to evade taxes
@8KX67Q95yrs5Y
Yes, we should allow citizens to handle their investments however and wherever they want, but the offshore income should be reported and taxed.
@8YJ6ZGY3yrs3Y
Yes if they are a citizen of that country
@8WNZXJ44yrs4Y
Only allow those within a certain range of money utilize the offshore bank accounts. Those who have abused it don't deserve them, but that shouldn't take them away from everyone unless there is too much corruption in it.
Deleted3yrs3Y
Yes, but close all loopholes for both citizens and corporations associated with offshore accounts, and mandate the reporting of offshore income to prevent abuse and tax evasion.
Deleted3yrs3Y
Yes, but eliminate all tax loopholes associated with offshore accounts and mandate the reporting of offshore income to prevent abuse and tax evasion. Also, hold political officials more accountable for their own immoral actions.
@78S5M875yrs5Y
as long as offshore income is reported
Deleted3yrs3Y
Yes, but eliminate all loopholes associated with offshore accounts and mandate the reporting of offshore income to prevent abuse and tax evasion. Also, hold political officials more accountable for their own immoral actions.
@B566JBWNew Democratic10hrs10H
Yes, as long as offshore income is reported and canadian corporation and business organisations should report theirs
@8RB2K9D4yrs4Y
Yes, but ban the wealthy and corporations from doing so
@8RDZZDL4yrs4Y
Yes, as long as offshore income is reported and there are laws passed to stop offshore tax loopholes
@8RB2K9D4yrs4Y
Yes, as long as offshore income is reported, and as long as they are under a certain income
@8PZ7LSP4yrs4Y
Yes, as long as offshore income is reported, though remove all loopholes to stop abuse of this
@8TF44GJ4yrs4Y
Yes, as long as offshore income is reported, and close loopholes in off-shore banking laws
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.